Lol if you wanna enjoy this song, leave ATRL. If Whine up was released today, everyone would be hating it now because it peaked at #29 on the hot 100, but everyone thought it was one of the biggest smashs of 2007 Just listen this and enjoy your moment lol

I think it will stabilize at #7 on itunes..but for now just keep expecting these huge dark red updates.

Um we come in here to you know, discuss the music. What does that have to do with music not the bling. you came up short with this one.

I remember the days when I didn't know ATRL and kworb existed. The days where I spent time watching TV, waiting for Lady Gaga to come on. I didn't care it was smashing, I still don't.



Good ol' days.

nostalgia is for geeks

So keen for the video

It'll really help me contextualise + better understand the song I reckon.

Also we've got another UK radio interview in 5~ hours!

Yet every post is about 'Why can't you all just enjoy the music' but yet there are no posts actually discussing the song!

Nice try to deflect though.

I just woke up and oh God
All the red updates

I mean, after ARTPOP she became a jazz covers act for three years straight

So please let LG5 succeed, not here for C3C and C4C

No, please shut up. ATRL back in 2009/2010 was just people giving their opinions on music, and not being chart-obsessed freaks.

2009: I like/hate this song.
Now: This is not a smash it will not become a hit so I don't like it.

Tragic

Thats because the focus is supposed to be the music. The charts aspect in this thread is obviously going to be monitored but melting down about it is useless. We're talking about people who are clearly trolling, like yourself or the people acting like their entire life has just been obliterated.

lol PI would smash even harder if it was released at that time. BTW smashed only cause of hype, if it was released now it would struggle to pass Closer

Kiiii after all the bullying the Monsters have done....it's funny to see this

^come up with receipts please, cuz as far as I've seen Monsters are one of the least vile fanbases around... most other bases drag way more and there are way too many obsessed gaga haters part of other fanbases who pretend to be monsters and then act disgustingly to make us look bad...but most of y'all are too dense to see it or so pathetic you pretend you don't see it...

Everyone who replied to my post or messaged me, thanks for the kind words and it's good to see some of you liked me being on here I'm not leaving cuz of the negativity and dragging getting to me, but rather because I feel I'm too old for this and that I have better things to do than track music's commercial performance and voluntarily browsing through all the negativity when I just love music and only ever enjoyed discussing ideas etc. I'll keep supporting Gaga (and a lot of other artists) by buying their music, attending their tours, and watching their performances, etc. I'm writing down all your twitters so I can follow you if I make one later. Enjoy your time on here and most importantly enjoy LG5, it might be her last pop album by the way things are looking

Do you see how unstable some of them become we're not even into the first full week yet. Tragic on all levels.

If gaga was an indie singer it would be perfectly acceptable to not consider the charts. But she is a popstar.
Having low sales affects the entire era. Interscope wont give her any money to promote, the tours will be ******, the outfits will be boring.

I already feel the artpop effect is rubbing over to LG5. Maybe interscope denied her request to hold elaborate performances and said just wear this half t shirt and go to the radio stations, we cant pay for TV interviews / slots anymore..

I havent seen any monster do that since 6 years, there are a few bad apples in every bunch but I seriously never saw any monster being to cocky even during the eve of the PI release.

monsters were not even overpredicting the sales