Rian. 7.5/10

I like the font.
The pictures are very small and you wouldn’t see that they’re Britney pics when it’s actual app size.

Element 8.5/10

Very cute. It fits Britney's branding very well. My major concern is that the design would not adapt well to the actual app icon size on a phone, so it would become hard to read and the dots and images would not be noticed.

Era 7.5/10

I love the idea and the pictures you used BUT the Britney Spears logo is exactly the same as on Pretty Girls promo images so it lacks a lil creativity. Also you should avoid using such small images when you're making a logo 'cause they're not gonna be visible AT ALL! It's all about going big and bold.

Fenrir 8.5/10

I like the font and positioning of the text.
I like how you included the pics of Britney but think they should've been a bit bigger.

Rian. 8/10

I love the concept and how you included the whole group.
Don’t like the black border tho.

Element 8.5/10

I really love the color you chose for the app, and the rounded borders are on point, especially the internal white one. Like with Britney, my concern is that this would not scale down well to an actual app icon size. The detail would become lost in the mix.

Era 8.5/10

I really love the gradient you used for the background. The cutting is amazing and the fonts go really well with everything as well. It could have done without the flares though. One of your best entries so far!

Fenrir 10/10

I like the fonts and that you decided to include all of the girls on it.
Overall I think it's a solid app that I could see 5H using.

Rian. 10/10

Standout entry for me.
Really really nice.

Element 9.5/10

I have to admit that I don't pay much attention to Gaga, so I'm not really sure how this hand symbol connects to her. But I'll take your word for it! I love the rainbow gradient towards the bottom of the hand, and the details in the design are great. It does unfortunately look a bit like a tree when scaled down, but I admire what you were going for. Adore the loading screen.

Era 9.5/10

Amazing entry! I really love it. I have no criticism over the icon itself as it's really good and creative. On the loading... window though it would have just looked better had the 'Loading' stayed constant with the dots increasing and decreasing rather than the blinking effect (which suits the logo really well). Fantastic job!

Fenrir 8.5/10

I like the overall design for the most part and could see Gaga using this.
My only gripe is that when it's shrunken down to actual app size it looks like a tree.

Rian. 10/10

Amazing concept, amazing execution. No flaws.

Element 10/10

This is exactly what I'd want in an app icon. It's unique, recognizable, vibrant and scales down appropriately. Bravo.

Era 10/10

This entry is literally perfect! It all looks so professional and sleek.
The execution was on point and it's all just wonderfully done.

Fenrir 9.5/10

Simple but strong design.

Rian. 9/10

I like it.
It looks like a real Zayn news app.
And I liked that you used his Zapp tattoo as the concept since it also looks like a vibrating speech bubble which to me looks like there is news.

Element 9/10

I like it and I appreciate the consistency with his tattoo. I would be hesitant to use the color pink with ZAYN though. His music and image doesn't strike me as that color. But this is a good design.

Era 8/10

I love the color you used as well as the font for 'Z'. However the font being origami-style it gave you an opportunity to use different gradients for Z rather than the just the background overlapping it but it still looks good anyway. Really like how it looks in the 'apps' section too.

Fenrir 7/10

Way too simple and kind of bland. I think this would've been a little stronger had you copied Zayn's tattoo with the same colors, border, etc. and had a yellow Z in the middle.

Rian. 7/10

I like the idea.
It does look kinda bland tho. There’s nothing eye-catching about it.
The cutting looks choppy too.

Element 9/10

I appreciate the minimalist design and how it directly connects to Tinashe's history and branding. I think the symbols could have been centered a little more on the image, or perhaps made a bit smaller. The blue color at the top is very nice. The bottom color might look better if it were a bit more saturated. But good work!

Era 7/10

Okay I'm not the biggest fan of Tinashe (I lover her and her music but I don't keep up with her much) but had I not known she is your artist I would have no idea how that logo represents her. But still it's a cool idea and I like the waves and the blue gradient is a perfect choice (maybe a bit darker more saturated look would have been better though) but the edges needed to be smoother.

Fenrir 7/10

Think it's too simple and bland to work. The app border could be a bit sharper too in a couple spots.

Rian. 7/10

Don’t really know what kinda app this would be.
The edges need to be rounded more. So it makes it look kinda unrealistic.

Element 9/10

Fun choice in picture that is easily identifiable as a Katy Perry app. I like the KP text at the bottom but it gets lost when scaled down. Usually I wouldn't love the combo of orange background with green hair, but it works pretty well here. I think a turquoise color in the background would have been cool as well.

Era 8/10

I'm not a huge supporter of having the artist's image in the app icon but here it works well (just like in URBAN's entry). I love the gradient you used and her image makes it look really colorful which represents Katy really well. The blending of her hair and the font could have been better though. The ads are very cute!

Fenrir 8/10

I like the colors you chose and the Katy pic but her hair seems a bit blurry in some spots.

Rian. 10/10

Really nice.
It kinda reminds me of GTA.
I’d kinda download it just to see what the app is about.

Element 10/10

I think this hits all the marks! Great work. It's a perfect combo of minimalism and artistic detail.

Era 8.5/10

Love the image and the colors/gradient and it fits the brief well. A bit of bold white text would have complimented it well imo but other than that no complains. Amazing job as usual!

Fenrir 9/10

I like that you went with a more artistic design for Avril.
Only thing I'd really change would be the picture; one with her smiling would've been nicer.

1. Cantaloupe 9.9
2. Hurem 9.4
2. LiMe 9.4
3. URBAN 8.75
4. Dancehall 8.25
5. Shendelzare 8
5. skwonderfactory 8
6. Kingie 7.5

Congrats to everyone else on making it to Round 8!