Discussion: Is Céline the only 90s diva that hasn't tarnished her legacy - Page 6

StammyWammy

Yes she is. Celine is a legendary queen and will remain as one until the end of time.

TheFireLexus

Quote:

Originally posted by T.C

It was you that brought her up darling. It wasn't my intention. For someone that isn't a legend, she must be on your mind a lot.

Don't be mad that your trolling backfired

-

OT: Celine has no legacy to tarnish as mentioned already

Please wake up

There is nothing you have said or will say that can change the fact that Celine Dion is a legendary singer.

IMPACTNET.

Quote:

Originally posted by TheFireLexus

Wow. A Janet Jackson fan mad at an actual, legendary female being acknowledged as such and trying to discredit her. What a surprise.

This entire thread was a failed attempt to discredit Celine's contemporaries and put her above them, yet I'm the one discrediting her? Have a seat. And next time you have a problem with what I post, reply via quote. Don't be a subliminal coward.

Quote:

Originally posted by halcyonday

Not a Janet Jackson fan coming for anyone.

Celine is a global legend. Not a forgotten, local fad who was known only for being a sister of someone famous.

Celine doesn't have 1/4th of Janet's impact or influence and she never will. Get over it. Janet is much more known and popular where I live than Celine is.

I find it funny how neither of you could dispute anything I said about Celine in any of my previous posts. All you can do is resort to tired Janet shade. Very telling, but not surprising coming from ATRL.

Quote:

Originally posted by T.C

Artists influenced by the "non Legend" Janet

Artists influenced by the "Legendary" Celine

N/A

Tutankhamun

Quote:

Originally posted by TheFireLexus

Wow. A Janet Jackson fan mad at an actual, legendary female being acknowledged as such and trying to discredit her. What a surprise.

I know right?

They spend 90% of the time on this forum coming for pop girls that are more successful than their favorite with all these ridiculous receipts.

T.C

Quote:

Originally posted by TheFireLexus

Please wake up

There is nothing you have said or will say that can change the fact that Celine Dion is a legendary singer.

Aww getting mad are we darling?

Dishing it out but can't take it.

Shoo.

T.C

Quote:

Originally posted by Tutankhamun

I know right?

They spend 90% of the time on this forum coming for pop girls that are more successful than their favorite with all these ridiculous receipts.

Again, who was it that brought her up in the first place in this thread? Certainly not her fans.

Sit.

Almighty Gaga

Quote:

Originally posted by TheFireLexus

Wow. A Janet Jackson fan mad at an actual, legendary female being acknowledged as such and trying to discredit her. What a surprise.

Quote:

Originally posted by halcyonday

Not a Janet Jackson fan coming for anyone.

Celine is a global legend. Not a forgotten, local fad who was known only for being a sister of someone famous.

Save-Me-Oprah

Quote:

Originally posted by Almighty Gaga

False. Celine holds the 2 ONLY french albums to be certified Gold in UK history, and the best-selling french album in history in the US. Same applies for most non-Francophone countries.

Won't even quote the part where you said she has no french classics.

D'eux is actually the best selling French-language album in history worldwide, not just the US.

The only other album that has come close to its sales is her followup album S'il suffisait d'aimer, which is the #2 best selling French-language album in history.

Tristan

chiliam

Quote:

Originally posted by IMPACTNET.

This entire thread was a failed attempt to discredit Celine's contemporaries and put her above them, yet I'm the one discrediting her? Have a seat. And next time you have a problem with what I post, reply via quote. Don't be a subliminal coward.

Celine doesn't have 1/4th of Janet's impact or influence and she never will. Get over it. Janet is much more known and popular where I live than Celine is.

I find it funny how neither of you could dispute anything I said about Celine in any of my previous posts. All you can do is resort to tired Janet shade. Very telling, but not surprising coming from ATRL.

Since you mention from when you live. Here in Asia, Celine has so many classic songs while nobody realize Janet`s songs

Travis Bickle

Celine is a huge Legend. Stop trying

Gossip_Boy

Y'all look dumb as hell trying to discredit Celine of all people. She's the definition of a global living legend whether y'all like it or not.

TheFireLexus

Quote:

Originally posted by T.C

Aww getting mad are we darling?

Dishing it out but can't take it.

Shoo.

Getting mad at what? Take what?

Celine Dion remains a legend. That's all there is to it.

Quote:

Originally posted by IMPACTNET.

This entire thread was a failed attempt to discredit Celine's contemporaries and put her above them, yet I'm the one discrediting her? Have a seat. And next time you have a problem with what I post, reply via quote. Don't be a subliminal coward.

Subliminal? Coward?

But okay. I'm quoting you now to tell YOU that Celine Dion is a legend, and you claiming "Janet is more popular" wherever you live will not change that. .

KKCuteCat

Quote:

Originally posted by cancer

She's a main female pop act, don't get me wrong, but when I think of Celine Dion I don't think of anything legendary. She was big with MHWGO and BYLM but other than that she hasn't made a lasting presence in the industry.

You know that her last tour in 2007 outsold every other female artists except for Madonna rite?

Orpheus

I think it's difficult to categorically state that the entire general public sees other 90s divas as having tarnished legacies. One can easily state, with this same set of thinking, that Celine doesnt have a tarnished legacy because the general public can't be bothered to actually care enough to put the spotlight of criticism on her.

cancer

Janet is actually a legend, that is a given.
Celine...not so much.

T.C

Quote:

Originally posted by TheFireLexus

Getting mad at what? Take what?

Celine Dion remains a legend. That's all there is to it.

Subliminal? Coward?

But okay. I'm quoting you now to tell YOU that Celine Dion is a legend, and you claiming "Janet is more popular" wherever you live will not change that. .

Right darling, she's that much of a legend that you have to put down other artists to elevate her.

Praise Mariallah

Quote:

Originally posted by IMPACTNET.

Edith Piaf, Jacques Brel, Salvatore Adamo, Michel Fugain and Serge Gainsbourg did far more for Francophone music than Celine. Celine is merely the only Francophone artist in the past 4 decades to find the success she has. That's not impact. That's simply a nice thing for her career. And all the people whose names I mentioned, have worldwide classics with Francophone music. Celine doesn't. There's no French song in her catalogue that stands out like "Non, je ne regrette rien" or "La vie en rose."

Answer me this: Why is francophone music today only successful in Francophone countries? If she's as influential as you claim, it should be that way in almost ALL countries, regardless of whether they're Francophone or not. Celine simply has been able to tap into both the Francophone and Anglophone markets very successfully. But that's all she's done. She didn't pave a path for others like her. It simply speaks to the success of her career. A legacy is something you leave behind that benefits others. Celine selling 250m records will only benefit her children when she dies..

Sis, you have to realize you're trying to have a logical conversation with 15-20 year old ATRLers who literally decided overnight to "stan" for Celine's #'s and safe blandness, they haven't actually listened to her discog or know much about her aside from MHWGO and some covers. They'd make the same kinda thread about Barbra Streisand but they only know one of her songs and it didn't have the impact!1! of MHWGO so alas.

slobro

She doesn't have a legacy to tarnish in the first place

J a y