Special Event: The Official Album/Artist/Singles Rate Signup Thread - Page 625

TRF.

Quote:

Originally posted by TRF.

Been thinking of making a rate thread called "The Weird Frontier", which is essentially kind of like a "This Was 2015" list but with critically acclaimed Electronic albums (since there was a surprising lack of said genre in those rates). The albums I've been thinking about were Oneohtrix's Garden of Delete, Jamie xx's In Colour, Arca's Mutant, Elysia Crampton's American Drift, Floating Points' Elaenia and Holly Herndon's Platform. Is it fine? I'm pretty sure it would tank but idk.

Bumping because I think nobody read this.

Latinazza

Where the heck is Ace?

MP2K

I finally gave Gallant a chance outside of Weight In Gold. My damns wig

def. adding him.

M A R N ✮

Quote:

Originally posted by Latinazza

Where the heck is Ace?

ignoring us all

I think i'm on his ignore list.

LoKoPaNdA

Ace & supa, can I be put in the waiting list for a Belinda singles rate? She has around 20 singles from 4 albums plus a few features. She's like the Latina Britney Spears I feel. The last major/pan-Hispanic female pop artist too.

M A R N ✮

2010s Grunge Rock & Metalcore Essential Rate:

what if I make this my title.
Emo Rock Essential Rate (features MCR, P!ATD, FOB, 30SOM, AA, BMTH , Blink 182)

Jesus I have so many great ideas for these rock fans.

With the Emo rate I'll add about 50 or 100 Emo songs from 2000 to 2016?
Big hits like my chemical romance, asking Alexandira, breakin benjami, all time low, blink 183, panic at the disco, murder on the dance floor, parkway drive, piece the veil, three days grace, bring me the horizon, bullet for my Valentine, the pretty reckless, in this moment, Paramore, a day to remember

Be Emo, metalcore, punk, I mean this would slayyy!

Please ace I don't think we have had something like this in a long time be good to add all the new bands too that have released

M A R N ✮

If you put it on th waiting list I'll think of 100 huge hits where everyone can rank!

makeme

The Janet Videography rate deadline is in less than two weeks if you haven't joined it you should now!!

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=1033826

makeme

I would be down for a Gwen disco rate.

jacklovesyou1

I love that 100 albums hate lmaooo i can imagine the fumes :LLL

Ace Reject

A lot of great ideas at the moment, but we're at 20 rates - maximum capacity!

Pink Matter

The Male Pop Icons of the 2000s Rate is now complete.
The winner goes to Kanye West for All Falls Down. Thanks for letting me host Ace!

Subomie

Haven't we talked about re-doing some of the first rates for a newer audience before Ace?

With the 5th anniversary of the rates coming up we should re-do some of the earliest ones, including the 90's Rebellion Rate featuring 3 of my favorite albums and Ray of Light

The first 2 rates as well, but like... I could predict how those would go.

Or re-jig em? Throw Parade and something else in the 1986 Rate? 25th anniversary then to 30th now?

I mean, I know we don't reuse albums for a reason, a good one, but there's so many people that weren't around then that would partake and it would be a cute celebration. Not even artist rates, just vs ones.

supaspaz

Quote:

Originally posted by Subomie

Haven't we talked about re-doing some of the first rates for a newer audience before Ace?

With the 5th anniversary of the rates coming up we should re-do some of the earliest ones, including the 90's Rebellion Rate featuring 3 of my favorite albums and Ray of Light

The first 2 rates as well, but like... I could predict how those would go.

Or re-jig em? Throw Parade and something else in the 1986 Rate? 25th anniversary then to 30th now?

I mean, I know we don't reuse albums for a reason, a good one, but there's so many people that weren't around then that would partake and it would be a cute celebration. Not even artist rates, just vs ones.

I've suggested this before, but the rate I want to redo is the first one ever. Would be a fun celebration of five years (!) of rates and interesting to see how opinions have shifted on those albums.

Ace Reject

I would TOTALLY be here for a redo of the first rate, and of the Rebellion rate. They're the only two I'd like to revisit, tbh.

Subomie

Quote:

Originally posted by supaspaz

I've suggested this before, but the rate I want to redo is the first one ever. Would be a fun celebration of five years (!) of rates and interesting to see how opinions have shifted on those albums.

Yes, somehow I feel it would be an even bigger mess now than then.

Quote:

Originally posted by Ace Reject

I would TOTALLY be here for a redo of the first rate, and of the Rebellion rate. They're the only two I'd like to revisit, tbh.

I know the Rebellion rate was the one most often brought up here by people who missed it too.

Ace Reject

Subby - you hosting something right now?

Subomie

My schedule is like Nadine's: empty.

supaspaz

Quote:

Originally posted by Subomie

Yes, somehow I feel it would be an even bigger mess now than then.

Maybe so. Rates certainly didn't feel driven by stans and sabotage in the beginning. But I still think it would be interesting. Femme Fatale has aged a lot better than Born This Way.

Subomie

Quote:

Originally posted by supaspaz

Maybe so. Rates certainly didn't feel driven by stans and sabotage in the beginning. But I still think it would be interesting. Femme Fatale has aged a lot better than Born This Way.

I have not played Femme Fatale or Born This Way in full in years, so it would be interesting to see how things have changed for sure