Looks: Beyoncé
Vocals: Beyonce
Dancing:Shakira
Impact: Shakira in Spain/Latin America, Beyoncé elsewhere
Music: Shakira

Shakira

Looks: Beyoncé
Vocals: Beyonce
Dancing:Shakira
Impact: Shakira in Europe + Latin America, Beyoncé in USA
Music: Beyonce

Shakira.

BEYONCÉ. Music, performance, vocal and sales wise

Shakira remains great in her own right though, her career is nothing to sneeze at.

Looks: Beyoncé
Vocals: Beyoncé
Dancing: Beyoncé
Impact: Shakira in Spain/Latin America, Beyoncé elsewhere
Music: Shakira

Beyoncé for everything except impact in Latin American

Shakira.

I always liked Shakira more.

She looks borderline anorexic in that picture

Music? The only flaw on that list. And while Beyonce can serve a Beautiful Liar/Shakira tea when she wants but you know Shakira could NOT do her routine at the Superbowl! So idk about dancing either.

I think Shakira for all

Looks: Shakira
Vocals: Beyonce
Dancing: Shakira
Impact: Shakira WW, Beyoncé US
Music: Shakira

Looks: Beyoncé
Vocals: Beyonce
Dancing: Shakira (I still remember her outdancing Bey in the Beautiful Liar music video. The latter even needed a stunt )
Impact: Shakira in Spain/Latin America, Beyoncé WW
Music: Beyoncé.

Winner: Beyoncé. But I love old Shakira.

Gurl please, she doesn't.

This one could really go either way based on opinion, both are legends

Beyoncé for all imo

Dancing? Shakira?

Stop comparing your faves to Beyoncé ATRL. It's not happening.

Shakira all the way.

Shakira.

Shakira by light years.

!!!!

Not a single bone showing though...

Looks: Beyoncé
Vocals: Beyoncé, by far
Dancing: Shakira for belly dancing, Beyoncé for everything else.
Impact: Beyoncé
Music: Beyoncé