All of his songs with other artists are terrible, and his most recent productions for Gaga sound like they're still stuck in 2008.

I don't hate redone he's a good guy and a good producer too.

I don't hate him, I just don't believe he has 'it' anymore. A lot of producers have a signature sound that basically is a stamp on the time. Gaga and RedOne have created some songs that will probably end up as pop evergreens but it's the same with Justin Timberlake and Timbaland. I mean they keep working together but if you released the 20/20 experience right after Future Sex/Love Sounds, it would have fitted aswell. I mean they probably will deliver, but I am not sure if RedOne can push Gaga;s sound the right way, I feel it rather would drag her back.

i love him actually and i cannot wait for his bops on LG5 ✔

They're usually the delusional stans who think she makes good music without him (she usually doesn't) and that she's the sole reason some of their work was good (she's not).

Remember when they blamed RedOne for "Judas" flopping? The production was fine. The song was just bad, especially those embarrassing lyrics and vocal delivery. And they love pretending his songs with her are amazing, but everything else is so bad. Like this person:

RedOne has plenty of good productions without Gaga and not all his work with Gaga is that great. Just Dance and most of the songs on The Fame were just recycled Kat DeLuna productions.

Because the Monsters aren't loyal to Gaga's work. The Fame came out and it was everything, then The Fame Monster was released and suddenly her older songs were crap. The same goes to Born This Way and ARTPOP, since they were highly praised (and defended) by her fan base when they came out, but now they just want to forget and her to comeback doing pop songs. Let's not forget that they were dragging people left and right to defend Gaga's jazz album too.

The Navy likes to pretend Rihanna's two first records are mixtape but at least we've been saying this since day one of stanning.