I would say just count the ones that aren't obvious trolls

These are good reviews, you have to count them. They justified their scores

Interesting that they all showed up after someone asked for the deadline extension. Maybe just count everything before the original Wednesday deadline for the official score.

Can we do Private Show next? And the new Bieber tracks too.

Wait y'all better count my Make Me review . Also Rise would only have like two reviews pre-extension.

Wow, why are the Katy stans so immature?

Yes.

rip my two honest reviews then

I agree with these suggestions!

Let me just leave this here...

As far as I can see, the only ones being immature are those complaining about legitimate, well-written reviews (and trying to get them discredited) just because you don't agree with the scores. That's how reviews work; some you're going to agree with, some you're not. I personally don't agree with scores of 2, 4.3, 5 and 6.5 for Rise but I haven't (and none of the others scoring Rise favourably) have complained about others' scores. The only ones complaining either scored low or didn't score at all.

Last time I checked, atrlcritic is open to all members of ATRL. I see no fair reason why Katy fans can't review a Katy song and have their scores count. Is it in the rules that this cannot happen? No. Katy's fans boosted Rise's total atrlcritic reviews from an "unofficial" 2 reviews (according to atrlcritic rules) to a much more respectable sample size of 15, and brought new life into this section that otherwise would not have been here.

A deadline extension was granted. Revoking the extension and only counting reviews made prior to said deadline because the scores aren't reflective of your personal opinion is in poor taste. Ignoring reviews that adhere to the very specific rules as stipulated in the OP shows bias and doesn't make me wish to review with atrlcritic again.

Just my two cents.

---

As far as upcoming reviews, my suggestions would be:

Britney Spears – "Private Show"
DJ Snake – "Let Me Love You (ft. Justin Bieber)"
Major Lazer – "Cold Water (ft. Justin Bieber & MØ)"
The Chainsmokers – "Closer (ft. Halsey)"

I lowkey co-sign with this

I highkey co-sign with this

You can't refuse to count peoples reviews because you don't agree with them.. just go along with it ..

Why would that be interesting, considering that the person who asked for that gave Make Me a better score than Rise?

there is no "issue" here, you're clearly downcast by the Make Me reviews but nothing that any of the ATRL members wrote in them isn't something that hasn't been said about it by every non Britney stan

And what was written is completely well within the rules of the thread.

Just take the L!

wow @ mods/organisers wanting to discount legitimate Rise reviews just because they disagree with the scores/are upset it has scored higher than Make Me. Not counting these well-written, perfectly acceptable reviews shows a clear sign of bias. I definitely will NOT be participating in atrlcritic in the future if this is the case!

Exactly, I'm shocked that moderator would even suggest such a thing.

Yeah sorry but discounting reviews just because you disagree with the scores is kind of unfair!