Let me revive this.
Any John Mayer stans on this site? I don't want him to get lashed too hard.

count me in

this is too cute

Perched!

I love that song he wrote called Spiritual

Room for Squares is the only album I've heard here sis! (Do I have to give up my blackness?)

Whew Why Georgia has to be top five. And Neon! YESSSSSSS. Lemme vote for the David Duke penis owner right now.

doing my scoring now. you should have it in 20 minutes

Just listened to 8701 for the first time and am listening to Room For Squares for the first time now; both cute albums. Will def. try and do this.

I feel like GRODT will be the album I like the least, but I haven't heard it yet so we shall see. Am kind of just basing it off the singles. As it stands, The College Dropout > Room For Squares > 8701.

didn't expect John to snatch me like that

the lowest score ever i gave was a 5...

John is obviously not popular with the ATRL audience and his music is just too different from the rest. Should have replaced him with someone else.

Personally, his is my favorite album among the 4, though.

Omg yas let me do this! Ready for YBIAW to SNATCH the crown

Then you just might like John's album as well
Yas you should pariticpate too Ace. And give Kanye your 11 while you're at it

That's what I hoped for . To have posters go away with something (whether that's a song or an album) they might like.
I was thinking about using JT, but supaspaz called dibs on Justified before I could after seeing the foolish and frankly ignorant posts he made about Jesse Williams BET Awards speech, I felt it only best to remove him from the rate

I do need all the Mayer fans I could get and I don't want him getting unnecessarily dragged so it would be great if you participated as well.

Oh and thank you Satan for sending in your scores
I just updated the OP.

I feel like...Justified was snubbed. That Xtina, Brit, JT rate ain't happening and it wouldn't be fair.

Oh my god i wanna do this to make sure John doesn't get dragged but I haven't heard the other 3

Ready for "All Falls Down" to slay the competition!

I think at the very least, Usher, Ye, and Fif are all pretty indicative of the type of male acts that were successful in the 2000s. JT would have been nice to have but, what can you do.
The Urban era of the 2000s was great , but let me know how you really feel about these albums
Listen to the singles at the very least to see if you like them then give their albums a shot . I would love it if more Mayer fans participated .
Ready for the #1 peak it so rightfully deserved.

I'm gonna do this!!

Yay