Quote:
Originally posted by Troye
If I remember right, to amend the Constitution, it either requires a 66% percent majority in both House of Reps and Senate or 66% of all the state legislatures to call for a convention (which is about 38 states). The latter is so rare that it has only happened once in the last 240 years and that was to repeal prohibition.
If done by the first method, it is then sent to the states to be ratified. Which must be approved by at least 3/4 of their legislatures or their ratifying conventions in at least 38 of the states. This is so incredibly rare and difficult. The reason for this is because the Founders believed it had to be so difficult that it would make it impossible for future governments to twist the very foundations of the Constitution to suit their needs.
|
If this is true it seems that it is even harder in the US than in Canada for a constitutional amendment, in Canada it is the 7/50 rule (7 of the 10 provinces which must account for at least 50% of the population), which is typically hard seeing as the various regions in Canada have quite different views (the west, the maritime, Quebec always likes to mess stuff up too)
but yah as you said the reasons for it being so hard to amend are valid as well, we don't want a new ruler coming into power and changing all the rules to make him or her the ruler forever, which is what happens in a lot of shady countries