Yeah she doesn't have time for this. She has better things to do.

Lady GaGa actually needs some rest.. maybe couple of days..
she can be a GUESS judge..and that would be better..

Bitch needs to perform ON the show, not be a judge.

Madonna should be the next AI judge

funny that simon said Gaga is the most relevant pop star in the world right now, when he also said beyonce the biggest star we've seen in the last 20 years..LOLLL..i guess its different meaning..? loll

I see Gaga being a unique mentor. Give her at least a few more years before upgrading her to judge.

And Ellen is doing very well so far...

Is he not allowed to love both of them?

BRITNEY SPEARS should be this new judge.

GaGa would never do it. I wouldnt mind her doing it as a guest judge though. dead @ her being able to sing better than 90% percent of her peers and she writes sings produces and arranges all her music. gwarl moo

Maybe as a mentor and guest performer yes but guest judge no cuz she is too busy to judge on this has-been show anyways. I love AI but I haven't really liked a winner since Carrie, Jordin is ok just doesn't bring the fire like Kelly and Carrie do. But yeah I hope she performs Telephone with Beyonce soon!