What's the point of ranking Beyuki's alberms, they're all full of fillers.

Hello alone was more successful than all of Lemonade's tracks/singles combined.
It's not really that interesting.

ST > Lemonade > 4 > B'Day > DIL > IASF

In terms of enjoyability. That's the only objective ranking.

In terms of quality just switch Lemonade and ST.

See I hate the trend of hating on "talentless" girls albums when this forum still bums Blackout and that Paris Hilton thing from a decade ago but Revival is just not good

Stars Dance is literally a soulless mess full of Rihanna demos and no soul or effort and it is enjoyable and full of bops. I think I hate revival because she tried to have personality and it didn't work because she's simply too boring

.

When the fomos thought Selena was coming for main popgirl status.

Revival produced 0 redeeming melodies.

This pic is so shady.

I'm not gonna lie. She had me fooled with Good For You.

But her performance ability and limited vocals really don't help her. Damn. She feels so basic even with songs as good as Hands to Myself.

revival is fine, its a bunch of demo shopping but so are all the other pop tarts (ariana demo mooghan etc) but what sets it apart is selenas taste for solid songs. She has an ear for a solid pop song that doesn't necessarily go for whats popular. Revival has a magnificent intro, Good For You is a fantastic sultry pbrnb esque song that none of her peers could pull off, sober's instrumentals could be right off a purity ring album etc. She makes great choices, sure it's not a grandiose statement or an innovative masterpiece but whos asking for that from selena gomez? She pushes her own boundaries and puts out music of better quality than her peers, which sets her above IMO

I totally agree that critical reception to LEMONADE has been totally over the top though I would argue 4 is her best album.

and dont get me started on picking at it for being a bunch of demos!!!! and stanning for anti in the same breath, i will not have it. nope not today

Exactly.

and then stanning for katy and suddenly caring for performance ability 2 for 2

Legend

oh Revival as a whole definitely sucks. her worst album by far. but it has its nice moments.

Katy is a good performer (even if not the strongest vocalist) else she wouldn't be invited to the SuperBowl or gross 200 million on tour.

I've never listened to Revival but I just played each of the tracks for like a minute on AM and I understand the appeal tbh.