Taylor.

Not when AOTY is the most important grammy out there.

Fearless:
Producer
Scott Borchetta (exec.) Nathan Chapman Taylor Swift

Speak Now:
Producer
Nathan Chapman Taylor Swift

Beyonce
Producer
Beyoncé Knowles (exec.) Ammo Boots Detail Jerome Harmon Hit-Boy HazeBanga Key Wane Terius Nash Caroline Polachek Rey Reel Noah "40" Shebib Ryan Tedder Timbaland Justin Timberlake Pharrell Williams

Lemonade
Mark Romanek Todd Tourso
Producer
Beyoncé Knowles (also exec.) Kevin Garrett Diplo Ezra Koenig Jack White Wynter Gordon Kevin Cossom MeLo-X Danny Boy Styles Ben Billions Boots Mike Dean Vincent Berry II James Blake Jonathan Coffer Just Blaze Mike Will Made It

GUESS

First: winning that award doesnt necessarily mean an album is good. Random Access Memories was **** and so were the two U2 albums that won it, for example.

Second: it's not about losing "credentials" it just doesnt mean that an album has had an actual, lasting impact on pop culture and that was always the case.

If you guys had a decent education you'd already know these things

I said that meaning that she can brag all she wants about being the only female artist winning that damn award twice but that doesnt mean she's earned it as a woman. there's nothing wrong in having male producers lol everybody has male producers

Its so obvious taylor is the more talented songwriter and producer here

Not according to the Grammys

Exactly

Taylor Swift has never produced a song in her life and she writes about her teenage school girl relationship or feuds with her "enemies", how on earth could that be interesting seriously

Your first point is your own subjective opinion, sadly the grammys mark the highest honor for music and theres no greater scale. you should know this

So? It's the current argument so we're using it

We tried album sales and y'all said Bey transcends sales now. Woo

I mean for a beyhive to use the 'keep clinging to receipts' excuse when y'all are NOTORIOUS for that

You know damn well the hive would impose her aoty to any argument if she had one

Of course its my opinion, that's why its not an obvious consequence for an album to be good when it wins aoty

YASSSSS Lord has been slaying her polls on atrl lately

Taylor is bigger than Beyonce US and Worldwide!

Interesting enough to sell millions and win 2 aoty awards

Taylor won over all albums release in a year twice including one of Bey's. Beyonce only won over 5 competitions or so in a some obscure genres or something.

AOTY was relevant the other day when the Hive were bragging that Lemonade will win AOTY and a year ago when they thought BEYONCE would win AOTY