Quote:
Originally posted by iHype.
Counting The Fame or The Fame Monster is really tricky. I count them as two different eras, but this site always counts them as one.
|
I think it's perfectly appropriate to count them as one; The Fame Monster's primary chunk of sales was (probably) the combo deluxe version rather than just from the EP alone, which we know only counts for approximately a fourth of the TF+TFM sales in the US. The EP wasn't even released as a standalone CD in some regions. The promotion for the eras sort of blended together as well, and the Monster Ball tour was more a tour for both albums since the Fame Ball tour was comparatively very small.
For the purposes of chart records, I count them together for the above reasons; they represent one singular, cohesive segment of Gaga's career. I also count TD: TCC and GGGB: R in much the same way, because it really doesn't make all that much sense not to. I mean, people can get all technical - "Janet/Michael/Bruce/etc. didn't get to rerelease, you can't say they're the same thing!!!" - but I just dismiss that as being stubborn or stuffy.