For what she did, I think that Nicole's original ban of 90 days was fair. Others have done much worse (e.g. GreasyBruce mocking the suicide of a 14 y/o Lady Gaga fan, countless personal attacks, violent behaviour; youkneekorn attacking openly transgender members with transphobic slurs; Vin's slew of graphic/violent/discomforting posts, joking about suicide, constant trolling; Lethal threatening people through PMs, etc.) and they weren't permabanned.

Sure, she was messy, but she was also one of the top posters on ATRL of all-time and introduced so many new people to the forum, as proven by her 20+ referrals. If Umich and Cherry were brought back, Nicole should be too, IMO.
