According to the Academy's criteria, she does. Whose rules are you going by? Your own opinions?
Anyway, soon enough we will find out which one of us is right. But if she does win, I'm sure that we can expect more Twitter outrage from certain people in the industry.
How on earth can someone submit just lyrics for a nomination? You make no sense at all. Gaga composed the music, the song was just lyrics when Gaga got it. That is 50% of the work. Fifty percent is way more than enough for a nomination. Just stop Lana stan
Gaga got her nomination. Even if she hadn't written a damn word, she would still be nominated for her production credit. The attempts tho
Anyway, soon enough we will find out which one of us is right. But if she does win, I'm sure that we can expect more Twitter outrage from certain people in the industry.