I love her. I don't get the "stick to acting" comments at all. She's not Demi, but she still ***** on Hilary Duff and Ashley Tisdale in terms of charisma, energy AND vocals and she always sings live despite her flaws. Plus Falling Down >>>>>>>>>>>
I love her. I don't get the "stick to acting" comments at all. She's not Demi, but she still ***** on Hilary Duff and Ashley Tisdale in terms of charisma, energy AND vocals and she always sings live despite her flaws. Plus Falling Down >>>>>>>>>>>
Ashley has improved so much in her live performances and she slays every time now!
Hilary Duff is good live too, I heard her and she surprised me!
And Hilary and Ashley have more energy and are more charismatic than her.
Selena is obviously the weakest singer out of them, but she's still young, so she might improve. Demi >>> Miley = Ashley >>> Hilary >>>>>>>>> Selena
I love her. I don't get the "stick to acting" comments at all. She's not Demi, but she still ***** on Hilary Duff and Ashley Tisdale in terms of charisma, energy AND vocals and she always sings live despite her flaws. Plus Falling Down >>>>>>>>>>>
She's a better actor than she is a singer; one of the best actresses on DC
Ashley has improved so much in her live performances and she slays every time now!
Hilary Duff is good live too, I heard her and she surprised me!
And Hilary and Ashley have more energy and are more charismatic than her.
Selena is obviously the weakest singer out of them, but she's still young, so she might improve. Demi >>> Miley = Ashley >>> Hilary >>>>>>>>> Selena
It seems like half of the Ashley performances I've seen were pre-recorded, but when she is live, she sounds alright. I don't think Ashley is a bad singer, I just find the tone of her voice to be too high pitched and kinda unbearable to listen to.
Hilary on the other hand, is the weakest singer and performer out of all the ones mentioned ITT. I find Selena to be a better vocalist hands down.
They all look like amateurs compared to Demi though.
It seems like half of the Ashley performances I've seen were pre-recorded, but when she is live, she sounds alright. I don't think Ashley is a bad singer, I just find the tone of her voice to be too high pitched and kinda unbearable to listen to.
Hilary on the other hand, is the weakest singer and performer out of all the ones mentioned ITT. I find Selena to be a better vocalist hands down.
They all look like amateurs compared to Demi though.
For me,
Demi > Miley > Selena > Ashley > Hilary
Selena is a better singer than Ashley and Hilary?
Everyone knows that she's the worst one by far.
It seems like half of the Ashley performances I've seen were pre-recorded, but when she is live, she sounds alright. I don't think Ashley is a bad singer, I just find the tone of her voice to be too high pitched and kinda unbearable to listen to.
Hilary on the other hand, is the weakest singer and performer out of all the ones mentioned ITT. I find Selena to be a better vocalist hands down.
They all look like amateurs compared to Demi though.
For me,
Demi > Miley > Selena > Ashley > Hilary
Ashley's voice is too high-pitched, that's true. But SHE HAS A VOICE, Selena can't even say the "You" part in "Falling Down" cause it's too high for her.
Selena is a better singer than Ashley and Hilary?
Everyone knows that she's the worst one by far.
Ashley and Selena are pretty close, so it's actually subjective. What makes you think Hilary can even hold a tune? I adore Hilary's music but she's a guilty pleasure (no pun intended), because I know she can't sing. At all.
Ashley's voice is too high-pitched, that's true. But SHE HAS A VOICE, Selena can't even say the "You" part in "Falling Down" cause it's too high for her.
IKR? Her voice is kinda cheesy for me, don't know how to describe it, though I love some of her songs.
Ashley and Selena are pretty close, so it's actually subjective. What makes you think Hilary can even hold a tune? I adore Hilary's music but she's a guilty pleasure (no pun intended), because I know she can't sing. At all.
Duca, Itsuky and A Muse make me laugh. Can't believe they're arguing about who is a better singer when obviously none of them (Ashley, Selena, Hilary) can sing.
Duca, Itsuky and A Muse make me laugh. Can't believe they're arguing about who is a better singer when obviously none of them (Ashley, Selena, Hilary) can sing.
Ashley can sing, she's not the best, but isn't bad.
Hilary can sing, but not just high notes.
Selena can't sing. She's a great actress tho.
I'm in public right now but I'll watch those when I get home. The Hilary performance isn't live though, lol. Compare that to all her other performances of that song POST-Most Wanted era. They are all lipsynced to the same pre-recorded track.
The Ashley performance better be really ****ing epic though if I'm going to get past how much I hate the tone of her voice.
