Discussion: Gaga didn't steal songwriting credits from Diane - Page 8

Dylangaga

LMFAO the haters are PRESSED!

IVY

Quote:

Originally posted by ♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

This is the writing credit which bases on the lyrics written for the song.
It makes total sense since Gaga herself admitted the song was finished in that sense.
She admitted she changed a few words here/there which is what Linda was saying.

Linda simply said Gaga has little to zero WRITING credit which came after deluded twitter monsters who THOUGHT gaga had writing credits, started attacking her.
She NEVER once complained about the nomination itself because those nominated are NOT just songwriters.

And Nile Rodgers happened to be there in the studio helping Gaga record the song and yet Gaga is credited as the sole producer which this is the reason she got her Oscar nomination, kinda fishy unless Nile who is one of the biggest producers ever has lied and has nothing to do with the production of the song. And why there's no other info about how gaga produced the song and worked on the production by herself?

pablozedd

Quote:

Originally posted by IVY

And Nile Rodgers happened to be there in the studio helping Gaga record the song and yet Gaga is credited as the sole producer which this is the reason she got her Oscar nomination, kinda fishy unless Nile who is one of the biggest producers ever has lied and has nothing to do with the production of the song. And why there's no other info about how gaga produced the song and worked on the production by herself?

Nile said himself his work on the song wasn't a big deal.. Maybe he didnt tought it was enough to get credited

Miracle

Quote:

Originally posted by Mariano

https://soundcloud.com/labofhookers/...-piano-version

this is how the song was supposed to sound.

Gaga changed the **** out of it, but the haters can rejoice. Leave them, seriously. That's the ONLY thing they will get this first half of the year.

Even chords are different lmao

Cyanide

Quote:

Originally posted by Buyonce1814

I don't know - I don't listen to demos. I prefer finished products.

Whilst countless songwriters have said the opposite.

It's not really off topic as it relates well to this situation too. I'm speaking in defence of Gaga. There's more to song-writing than writing the words imo. If you contribute to the components of the song whether it's adding an ooh or aah then I believe you should get a credit.

It's ATRL. Hypocrisy runs rife.

I don't think you even get why you're wrong, you're just seething so hard over Beyoncé that you can't even take the 10 seconds to realize how different the situations are. Beyoncé gets dragged because she LITERALLY paid for credits on multiple songs she had no part in. Gaga, a SONGWRITER, never even claimed to have written the song. Receipts have been posted of her saying that Diane came to her with the demo. She did however compose the song and contribute to the lyrics, so she gets a credit and deserves her nomination no matter how you slice it's. Sorry, Hive.

Scandal & Media

Welp.

RT Air

Quote:

Originally posted by Cyanide

Gaga, a SONGWRITER, never even claimed to have written the song. Receipts have been posted of her saying that Diane came to her with the demo. She did however compose the song and contribute to the lyrics, so she gets a credit and deserves her nomination no matter how you slice it's. Sorry, Hive.

.

/endthread

Sinvius

Quote:

Originally posted by dirrtydiana

I disagree with this. As a performer myself, I cannot take credit for making a "minor contribution" to the performance which was actually choreographed by other people. I am just the performer and Linda, along with the industry, is looking at this as a writer, not an ATRLer. Bey teas tbh.

I don't even know where to start with your Cara Delevingne ass, put that eyebrow pencil down and re-evaluate your choices, performer.

♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

Quote:

Originally posted by IVY

And Nile Rodgers happened to be there in the studio helping Gaga record the song and yet Gaga is credited as the sole producer which this is the reason she got her Oscar nomination, kinda fishy unless Nile who is one of the biggest producers ever has lied and has nothing to do with the production of the song. And why there's no other info about how gaga produced the song and worked on the production by herself?

Nile was there but how much did he actually help?

According to your own wiki receipt he did NOTHING more than to SUGGEST Gaga to change in sing in the earlier vocal note. Maybe his involvement was minimal and therefore he, himself didn't feel like it would be right to get credited? Because there would be no issues at all getting him credited and nominated if he did contribute significantly. There's enough place for another person to be nominated alongside Diane/Gaga.

What other info do you need when it's coming out from Diane's mouth herself? Jesus

Anyways, i'm glad Linda apologized.

BabyCantYouSee

Quote:

Originally posted by ♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

Nile was there but how much did he actually help?

According to your own wiki receipt he did NOTHING more than to SUGGEST Gaga to change in sing in the earlier vocal note. Maybe his involvement was minimal and therefore he, himself didn't feel like it would be right to get credited? Because there would be no issues at all getting him credited and nominated if he did contribute significantly. There's enough place for another person to be nominated alongside Diane/Gaga.

What other info do you need when it's coming out from Diane's mouth herself? Jesus

Anyways, i'm glad Linda apologized.

Gaga's manager probably threatened her.