The first one
Im struggling to name more than 3 of the other judges

The first one... but just imagine Mariah and Simon together.... it would be epic!

The original; no other compares.

Obviously Randy, Paula, Simon. Especially when Paula was drunk off her ass.

All of them are tragic except for the original one

Lmao @ Ellen being on there, I forgot all about that.

The first set of judges, followed by Nicki & Mariah. Their feud>All of J.Los seasons

What kind of question is this?
Simon, Paula and Randy are the three most iconic judges on any show.

The original, and then Steven, Randy and J.Lo >>>>> the rest. The Nicki/Mariah feud was boring to me, and seemed pointless as well as being desperate trying to get viewers back.

Haven't bothered with it since season 12.

I quite liked Kara, though. Ellen was funny but I never understood why she was even on the show to begin with.

KARA SLAYEDTTTTT... QuEEN OF DEFENDING WHOEVER THE PRODUCTION WAS UNFAIR !!!

The first one

Kara was terrible

I still don't get the purpose of choosing Ellen as a judge.

Wait. Why was Ellen a judge?

Original panel >>>

The original foooooorrrr sure.

The original and then Mariah's panel.