Yes they both are

Basically the Army, Katycats, Barbz, Madonsters and Lana stans will say 'Bey is but Gaga isnt'
So pathetic and predictable.

OT: yes both are flawless performers. Gaga has better vocals tho

Gaga is

I think Gaga is a good performer. She's underrated by her haters but she's overrated by her fans.

I have yet to see something exceptional.

Beyoncé is

Gaga is in line with her peers, idk why y'all clain she's somehow a better entertainer/performer than Katy,Rih.

Monsters tend to think she's above her peers in general, but she actually was left behind. She's struggling to keep up with them nowadays.

Beyonce is a boring performer, but she has a nice voice which does automatically put her in a league above most, so I guess the OP didn't lie.