It's not like gaga hasn't done everything in her power to make her undesirable to the straights (Instants gaydar is clearly broken). She clearly doesn't want them
I honestly don't get the Christmas song drags. It's not like every pop star's Christmas song is as successful as AIWFCIY
As IF stans of girls who can't crack iTunes Top 1,500 95% of the year don't wish and hope their fave could ever manage a classic with the power to chart on Hot 100 every single year.
The U.S. and Europe are like two completely different galaxies when it comes to Madead's career. It's kind of astounding how she still has such a strong fan base over there while the U.S. doesn't even use any of her post-80's music.
Even at gay clubs, I never hear Madead, and I've heard Minooneknows played there.