These 3 songs are arguably the biggest flop singles from a major pop girl this decade and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that but which single is more successful?

Criminal was the biggest song.

X.O > G.U.Y. > Criminal.

Poor Deadney.

Idk about most successful but XO is the best one

Criminal went #1 in Brazil, while B.Y.E. (Billboard Charts) didn't reach the Top 40 anywhere.

Criminal but only because of the controversy.

It charted at #1 in the hearts of Monsters all over the world so that's all that matters.

Criminal was successful in parts of Europe. XO was a moderate hit in the US. G.U.Y was nothing.

Criminal > XO > G.U.Y.

XO was on a Grammy nominated album plus Beyoncé sung in on her WW tour infront of millions

Well, XO was a lead single + all the strategy and stuff. That one.

Criminal.

NNNnnn funny about that since Brazil does NOT have a singles chart, only albums chart.

My fellow army members and their elusive charts.

not number 1 in Brazil the expose

Criminal 800K
XO 1,3M
GUY 100K

But considering that XO was a lead single of ST and Criminal was the fourth single off of FF, the latest is the biggest among them.

Criminal.

I miss the FF era.