Arguably Madonnas two bottom ranked albums. Which is better and why?

Hard Candy is better than MDNA and Rebel Heart, any other answer is wrong

Hard Candy.

I like every track on it.

MDNA however I liked about half and didn't even buy it

Hard Candy

MDNA has some bops on it

Hard Candy has 'Incredible' + 'Spanish Lesson' so automatically MDNA >>

Aside from the cheeseball verses, I really liked Incredible's chorus and the whole manic vibe it had particularly towards the end.

But Heartbeat and Miles Away >>>>> than anything on MDNA imo. I dont think theres a single song off of MDNA that I respect.

hard candy by far


4 minutes, beat goes on, give it to me, miles away, shes not me>>>>>MDNA

MDNA has "I'm Addicted", "Love Spent", "Falling Free", "Gang Bang" and "Beautiful Killer"
HC has "Devil"

...

So MDNA

Hard Candy has higher highs so I'll go with that!

MDNA

MDNA

MDNA is bad but Rebel Heart is her worst. Hard Candy is cute.

This.

HC has Candy Shop so

Candy Shop > everything post Ray of Light

Hard Candy but MDNA for having Falling Free, Beautiful Killer, Masterpiece, Love Spent, Some Girls and Gang Bang.

Hard Candy has Miles Away so it automatically wins

Hard Candy is consistently mediocre whereas MDNA is less consistent but definitely has better highlights. So MDNA.

HC is by far her worst album.

Hard Candy is her worst album,so MDNA.

Also Love Spent and Masterpiece >>> every song from Hard Candy.

Hard Candy is even better than Confessions on a dance floor so that.