The female winning even with a lacklustre song. Welcome to ATRL.
I think JTWYA is just as good as WMYB, they both have certain weaknesses but both are great pop songs which launched the careers of two of the biggest male artists in the current pop landscape. Both have far better songs though.
The Grammy Award winning song Just the Way You Are. It's also the only #1 and sold above 10 million copies worldwide. It was also on the IFPI best selling tracks the year it was released. The other lessers can only wish.