Poll: 1989 Vs RED.... better album?? - Page 4

ahauntingnearu

1989 is a generic pop record. it's very solid, but it's not amazing or profound, artistically-speaking. it has 3-4 fantastic songs, a bunch of good songs, and a few not so good songs.

red, on the other hand, has her career highlights (SOG, Treacherous, ATW, HG, BA) and has a bunch of really great songs. its biggest issue is the inconsistency. for example, you have the amazing ATW, followed by the hideous 22. Red has some of her best songs mixed with some of her worst (SSS, 22, etc.). if she had narrowed down the tracklisting to 11-13 songs, Red would be an even better album.

it's maybe less consistent than SN, but it has higher highs than SN and could've potentially been her best album.

anyway, 1989 is a basic album for children in comparison to Red. it's immature (overall) and fun, but it's no phenomenal album

Whiskey Mouth

Red. 1989 is more consistent and doesn't have filler like Red, but Red has amazing highlights that are better than everything on 1989.

Both albums are genius, though.

Whiskey Mouth

Quote:

Originally posted by ahauntingnearu

1989 is a generic pop record. it's very solid, but it's not amazing or profound, artistically-speaking. it has 3-4 fantastic songs, a bunch of good songs, and a few not so good songs.

red, on the other hand, has her career highlights (SOG, Treacherous, ATW, HG, BA) and has a bunch of really great songs. its biggest issue is the inconsistency. for example, you have the amazing ATW, followed by the hideous 22. Red has some of her best songs mixed with some of her worst (SSS, 22, etc.). if she had narrowed down the tracklisting to 11-13 songs, Red would be an even better album.

it's maybe less consistent than SN, but it has higher highs than SN and could've potentially been her best album.

anyway, 1989 is a basic album for children in comparison to Red. it's immature (overall) and fun, but it's no phenomenal album

22 and Stay Stay Stay are amazing

Taylor Swift

Do people who drag SSS understand the song?

ahauntingnearu

Quote:

Originally posted by Whiskey Mouth

22 and Stay Stay Stay are amazing

They're cute?

Finny

State Of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Red vs Blank Space
Treacherous vs Style
I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of The Woods
All Too Well vs All You Had To Do Was Stay
22 vs Shake It Off
I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
The Last Time vs How You Get The Girl
Holy Ground vs This Love
Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
The Lucky One vs Clean
Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Starlight vs You Are In Love
Begin Again vs New Romantics

Mess, I prefer Red but 1989 won 9-7

HandsOn

State Of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Red vs Blank Space
Treacherous vs Style
I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of The Woods
All Too Well vs All You Had To Do Was Stay
22 vs Shake It Off
I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
The Last Time vs How You Get The Girl (

)
Holy Ground vs This Love
Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
The Lucky One vs Clean
Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Starlight vs You Are In Love
Begin Again vs New Romantics

RED: 7
1989: 9