in my opinion its Red.. All those countryish songs with a pop tinge like starlight , lucky one , red , stay stay stay or begin again <33

1989 only has good singles.. Rest all is filler stuff

1989 is my favorite album, but Red is her best album.

Red is easily Taylor's best album.

1989

Red >>>

Sacred.

Red, before she decided to sue random people.

Red is by far the better album

Red >>>>

I like Red the most out of her albums.

Red.. ha magnum opus

1989 is the better alber while Dead has better individual tracks.

RED is great, but it has a lot of duds, and by duds I mean the worst songs of her career. Yet, the other half has some of the best songs of her career. 1989 is a lot more cohesive and every song is listenable, unlike the other.


1989>>>>

State Of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Red vs Blank Space
Treacherous vs Style
I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of The Woods
All Too Well vs All You Had To Do Was Stay
22 vs Shake It Off
I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
The Last Time vs How You Get The Girl
Holy Ground vs This Love
Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
The Lucky One vs Clean
Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Starlight vs You Are In Love
Begin Again vs New Romantics

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=700854&page=3

interesting development. tie broken

Although, not true, what does that have anything to do with the question

1989 as an album.
Red has higher highs.

???

Sacred is far better.

State Of Grace vs Welcome to New York
Red vs Blank Space
Treacherous vs Style
I Knew You Were Trouble vs Out of The Woods
All Too Well vs All You Had To Do Was Stay
22 vs Shake It Off
I Almost Do vs I Wish You Would
We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together vs Bad Blood
Stay Stay Stay vs Wildest Dreams
The Last Time vs How You Get The Girl
Holy Ground vs This Love
Sad Beautiful Tragic vs I Know Places
The Lucky One vs Clean
Everything Has Changed vs Wonderland
Starlight vs You Are In Love
Begin Again vs New Romantics

Poor 198Decline.

Red

All Too Well >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 1989

Red >>>>>

1989 is more cohesive, and, as a whole, I enjoy listening to it more from start to finish, but the highs on Red are too high for me not to love it more. Both are absolutely incredible though.