Originally posted by Kworb

It's okay, not very original, kind of outdated. The thread got a lukewarm

Originally posted by Kitt

It's like Rider's entry for the ATRL Feature round during his season in thread form.

Originally posted by Superiore

Well developed and surely interesting but it's something I've seen already a dozen times around the site these past years. This also looks like something more fitting for the Apprentice challenge (a new feature for ATRL) and, guess what, a magazine has been submit for that challenge in the previous seasons too.

Originally posted by Tiberius

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Gyal, you knew a magazine was already in the works based on the comments. But kudos on the mock ups in the OP.

Originally posted by Kworb

An unoriginal thread with annoying replies. I didn't even know it was for this game, I already rolled my eyes at it a few times.

Originally posted by Kitt

I've about seen this topic a million times but it's always a fun one to read through.

Originally posted by Superiore

Something I've seen before too but it sparked some interesting replies and the members of the site always get involved in threads like this.

Originally posted by Tiberius

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

I think I'm indifferent. We've seen similar challenges/entries, whether it be taking out a section on ATRL, how to improve ATRL, suggestions in general regarding ATRL...blah blah blah.

Originally posted by Kworb

Eh, same old. Your thread was a moderate hit though, I'll give you that.

Originally posted by Kitt

BlazingLovatic's post voiced my thoughts on the thread when he said "What's the point of asking this on a primarily LGBT forum? The responses will predominately be one-sided anyway." But you did well nudging posters to expand on their viewpoints to facilitate further discussion.

Originally posted by Superiore

I don't really blame Buddy for having come for the originality of this. May you have taken inspiration from his thread or not, they're really similar in their foundations. You didn't change the matter of discussion but I think the nature is just the same one.

Originally posted by Tiberius

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Decent critical thinking question was posed but I swear I've seen this thread before. Or maybe it was on Reddit? Nice job keeping the thread alive till the bitter end but I felt like I was listening to a therapist with each of your reply..."I see. But how does that make YOU feel/what do YOU think/YOU etc." But maybe I'm cynical and you were genuine in all your questions.

Originally posted by Kworb

Oh I loved this thread, I had no idea it was for this game. I even posted in it. Well done.

Originally posted by Kitt

For such a simple question I'm surprised at how many pages this received. But I understand this is a common occurrence that we all share and have our peeves, stories, or inquiries about.

Originally posted by Superiore

Probably the one thing I didn't have the feeling to have seen before. I'm surprised it gave birth to so many pages but that's also due to you managing to carry the conversation and not in a forced way. P.S.: self check-outs rock!

Originally posted by Tiberius

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Hm. I think I like it? It's just so random. Not ludicrous like ks_dollar's thread (or whatever his name is) but quirky like you. It's not stellar but it's not repetitive. People love talking about themselves and sharing their experiences so congrats on being savvy snatching on of the bigger replied threads.

Originally posted by Kworb

At least it's something different, even though the replies don't really add much and there is no discussion.

Originally posted by Kitt

Wait I love this. I'm personally intrigued but I know ATRL don't have the time for this.

Originally posted by Superiore

Magician Mario here to cast a saving spell. This might not have been the thread to attract the big mass of the ATRL's gee-pee's comments, because it involved some actual reading. I've always loved this kind of threads, or articles when they're in blog/magazines. The underlying aspect of the thread is not something original but the way you put it there surely is. A+ for the extra effort in the OP.

Originally posted by Tiberius

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

I know this is somewhat like Citrus' thread but I liked it. The descriptions reminded me of the Briggs-Meyer test and I love that sort of ****. And I'm also a geek for anything magic. Too bad ATRL didn't gobble it up. All. That. Text. in the OP.

Originally posted by Kworb

Meh, a thread with people just listing locations.

Originally posted by Kitt

Basic.

Originally posted by Superiore

I think I've seen threads right like this one a million times but at least it's never boring to read about what the people dream and the reasons why.

Originally posted by Tiberius

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Meh. Another variation thread.

Originally posted by Kworb

The thread had potential but the replies are really boring. ATRL's users ruined it for you.

Originally posted by Kitt

Some of the answers in there aren't even stereotypes.

Originally posted by Superiore

The responses this got, amidst of all the mess too, were probably the most interesting to read out of all the threads you guys proposed. I liked how you didn't only focus it on gay stereotypes, even though those are obviously what gathered the most attentions in here.

Originally posted by Tiberius

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Another variation/recycling of a similar thread. Or maybe my memory is just **** and I saw something similar somewhere else. Regardless, I'm not a huge fan only cuz I don't like the topic. Stereotypes, for the most part, I try to defy. It's silly when people process and catalogue complete strangers just cuz of your looks or one passing comment you make.

Originally posted by Kworb

This is a recurring discussion, but it's always fairly interesting.

Originally posted by Kitt

It's funny to read the responses and then look who the poster's faves are in their sig/avatar.

Originally posted by Superiore

Nothing so quirky or over the top but definitely a good thread. I can definitely see you put effort into your thoughts for the OP. I liked it.

Originally posted by Tiberius

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

You're unlucky that I (and even older, Kworb) have been around since 2011 (2002). I've seen this thread multiple time and even I made a variation of it. I think it was to shade Beyoncé and HaHa. The thread could have lasted a bit longer had you given video examples or just had shady examples that targeted.