I still think we should group Demi, Selena, Ariana, 1D and Justin together for an ultimate rate.

Dead Petz doesn't fit in at all.

Are we ever gonna do that grand rate composed of the first 100 winners of our own rates? We had been discussing that for so long.. I remember we were just ahead of the first 100 when the idea popped up and now we're at 218.

Bieber vs 1D vs Troye Sivan vs Years & Years is what should happen.

We can add In Rainbows to this mix. Maybe remove Arctic Monkeys

I approve it, it should start at Christmas tbh

No. If anything remove the Mumford & Sons album

But yes, In Rainbows would be a great addition.

Yep. It needs to happen. It could be huge

This is a great idea. Let's remove Mumford, so we can do a series.
Part1 Viva vs Rainbows vs Camino vs AM
Part2 Rush of Blood vs The Bends vs another Black Keys vs another AM album

How many albums have to be included in a rate? Is 4 the minimum?

You can probably get away with 3 if Ace is in a good mood but I think 4 is the minimum because we want to rate as many albums as possible

Nicki Minaj Videography Rate
Rate Host: DevonRoars
Winner: Anaconda

With the crap you just pulled, you should never be allowed to host anything ever again

Need to steal this idea.

no one likes a tease

Well I still think Ariana/Demi/Selena needs to happen even if there isn't a replacement for Miley.

I don't see how Tinashe doesn't fit. She wants to be a pop girl pretty bad.

I would participate. Radiohead get 10s for everything.

Part 1: Viva vs Rainbows vs Camino vs AM
Part 2: Rush vs Bends vs Rubber Factory (because Brothers has already been used) vs Whatever People Say I Am

Part 3:Parachutes vs Ok Computer vs Blakroc vs another AM album.

How many parts are you planning to do?