Quote:
Originally posted by Adonis
Rachel Maddow said that not a single candidate won the debate. It was actually the Democratic Party that won the debate. I would have to agree. The adults were in the room.
|
Didn't see the segment yet, but based on what you said I will say I agree and disagree with my good sis Rachel Maddow, or at least to a certain extent. Rather, I agree and
kinda agree, I'll start with the latter:
1) While I would mostly agree that there was not one standout, the conclusion I draw is instead, that 2.5 people "won" the debate, rather than no one won.
- Hillary came out with a clear strategy and got most if not all of the boxes checked that I would have had on my list: finally went on the offensive against Bernie when the very nature of her campaign put her on the back foot against the upstart challenging her from the left (grilling him on guns), mentioning the two main arguments her supporters have in favor of supporting her "I'm the candidate who gets things done" and subtly insinuating that she's the one we need in order to beat republicans (again, I disagree, but it's a good notion to run on), and lastly, definitely putting the email "scandal" behind her, at least in the minds of non-insane voters.
- Bernie Sanders, while he could have prepared better, finally appeared to the general public (not young internet users or people at his rallies) as an actual candidate with policies, rather than the faceless concept of "socialist drawing big crowds" which media narratives reduced him to previously. Being generally considered charismatic and with a populist message, getting that message out on the big stage was the main thing currently on Bernie's agenda, it's why his supporters were whining about a lack of debates, and he did it well earning probably more crowd support than anyone else.
- Martin O'Malley - while his winning would be the upset of the century at this point in what is a two-person race at best - he at least made his debut appearance to the GP, didn't make a fool of himself, and appeared "presidential" overall. If nothing else, he poised himself for the prospect of VP, a good cabinet position, a better presidential run in the future, my sugar daddy, etc. I also give him bonus points for being the only one who didn't give an answer I felt to be a gaffe.
So instead of saying no one won, I'd say 2-3 people won, in so far as they accomplished the goals they had to have set for themselves pre-debate. Hillary probably gets a B+, Bernie a B, O'Malley like, a C-.
2) On the other hand, I do wholeheartedly agree that the democratic party won overall. The main problem I had with the DNC's decision to have such few debates is that debates draw headlines. By allowing republicans to run rampant with, what is it, twice as many official debates(?), they are essentially allowing them to control the national conversation. We shouldn't be discussing how hard we want to persecute women for making decisions concerning their bodies, or how fervently we want to demonize immigrants. I like that I'm hearing regular people talking about free/affordable college now, things like that are why it's a net win for the democratic party, and liberals/progressives in general.
_________________________
Now this is once again purely anecdotal, but related to my first point. About an hour ago, Obama, with Joe Biden by his side just interrupted The View which my mom and I were watching (after Wendy

). I brought up how Biden missed his chance not showing up to the debate, which prompted her to say she now supports Sanders. Not
zealously, she certainly didn't sound like a 20 year old collegiate tumblr user in her support, but this is big coming from a black woman in her 50s, generally a moderate democrat who was very pro Bill Clinton, and raised me with the old "Bill was the first black president" saying. Keep in mind we're a family which generally does not discuss politics (me being a far left progressive, my mom being a more moderate democrat, and my older brother being a conservative-leaning independent, it's a topic we shy from), so it's not like I've been lowkey campaigning for Sanders or ever even mentioned that's who I support. This is what
visibility does, and why candidates like Bernie Sanders desperately wanted it.