Album: The Fame Monster
Singles: The Fame Monster
Tour: 1989
Acclaim/Awards: The Fame Monster
Impact: The Fame Monster
Media: The Fame Monster
Overall: The Fame Monster

1989 is close on all fronts, though.

Poll added. It's really close, i can't choose.

The Fame Monster

TFM.


Bigger, better and more global.

Both!

1989 by miles and miles...

Easily 1989 since it didn't need a re-release to sell.

That's not even fair to compare one era to two.

1989 is much bigger.

The Fame was selling a lot without the re-release though.

what kind of flop logic is this?

TF alone outsold 1989

Poker Face, Bad Romance, Telephone, Alejandro were all more global than any 1989 single

1989 by light years

The Fame Monster era minus The Fame alone was more impactful and more iconic than 1989.

Also, Poker Face alone > any of the 1989 singles.

TFM.

This is a no brainer. Obviously TFM.

Albums: The Fame + Monster vs 1989
Singles: The Fame Monster vs 1989
Tour: The Monster Ball Tour vs 1989 World Tour
Acclaim/awards: The Fame Monster vs 1989
Impact: The Fame Monster vs 1989
Media: The Fame Monster vs 1989
Overall: The Monster vs 1989

It was Gaga's peak, which is basically untouchable by any pop girl not named Britney, Madonna or Whitney.

TFM. More global and more iconic.