Madonna is THE INTERPRETER , she doesn t need to have Whitney s voice to deliver so many emotions

1000 great vocalists can die to make feel so many emotions like Madonna on a performance , and her vocals are good , not commenTs about her dancing and her artistry , she is the whole package , THE PERFORMER -THE ARTIST

That's why critics are praising her vocals in her actual tour ; )

I think it's so funny how Madonna stans always say how singing is the least important talent, yet do the most to try and prove that she can sing. She can't sing. She has never been able to do so in any point of her career.
All this "unique voice" talk....that has absolutely nothing to do with being able to sing. Taylor Swift has a unique voice. So does Rihanna, so does Bob Dylan, so does Aretha Franklin, so does Stevie Wonder. The most celebrated artists and performers all have "unique voices". Some of them, however, can sing. Some cannot. Madonna is in the "cannot".
Her songs aren't the hardest to cover. Usually, people who can sing don't cover her songs, so we're only used to hearing her "sing" them.

Well with a reason you sound pressed, because after all Madonna, despite not having a unique voice or not being able to sing in your opinion, is the bigger act than all the ones you listed.

OP: the oversinging and screaming of most singers don't manage to express the emotions of Madonna's songs.

not if you have good breath control.

LOL. "When all else fails, just refer to sales." And I didn't say she didn't have a unique voice, so IDK where that came from.
She might very well be bigger than all of them. She still cannot sing.



If only she could sing, though.

Yet they're more acclaimed than her.

Well would ya look at that