Picture 2 is my type. I love
modern rustic design.
I would love to have a wood slat wall as an accent wall, using reclaimed wood (possibly grayish-white) since the texture would be less polish.
Not a fan of stones that have too many patterns since I find them too busy and gaudy. I prefer if they are more subtle (If I remember correctly, my sister has a solid white quartz countertop over dark cabinets, very clean and modern)