Originally posted by Planet Mars

Hasn't Musicbox sold 30M+ WW?

Originally posted by XStaticProcess

Sis we are not talking about who outsold who in UK.Papa Don't Preach and La Isla Bonita has bigger sales than Without You.

And South Kore and Taiwan sales are counted for Music Box's 27M.Nice try Jan.

According to Mariah's receipts thread:
WY:3.4M

Papa Don't Preach:3.850.000
La Isla Bonita:3.750.000

LOL

OT:Madonna's TIC!

Originally posted by idkher

Was I saying they weren't counted? I was responding to you saying East Asia only gives her 5k additional sales...

Lmao @ a difference of 300k when none of those are reliable numbers whatsoever. Without You remains the bigger hit, the certifications do not lie

Originally posted by musicman101

at you forgetting "Let Go" by Avril Lavigne that sold 17,000,000 worldwide

Originally posted by gracemckenna98

Originally posted by Planet Mars

Hasn't Musicbox sold 30M+ WW?

Originally posted by J a y

I thought it would've been 12M, unless she's managed to sell an extra 3 million copies in the last two years.

1. Usher – Confessions – 15.000.000 (2004)
2. Green Day – American Idiot – 15.000.000 (2004)
3. James Blunt – Back To Bedlam – 12.500.000 (2004)
4. Norah Jones – Feels Like Home – 12.000.000 (2004)
5. Kelly Clarkson – Breakaway – 11.000.000 (2004)

I still don't understand the 15-16M total of The Fame Monster either.

1. Lady Gaga – The Fame (Monster) – 13.900.000 (2008)
2. Coldplay – Viva La Vida or Death and All His Friends – 9.000.000 (2008)
3. Taylor Swift – Fearless – 8.100.000 (2008)
4. Beyoncé – I Am... Sasha Fierce – 7.000.000 (2008)
5. Kings of Leon – Only by the Night – 6.600.000 (2008)

Unless TFM sold more copies than ARTPOP and Cheek to Cheek combined in the last two years. #whenwillurfave