Do you think the way to punish these sex offenders would be to castrate them or chop their penis off? Do you think it'd be a good deterrence?

Yeah.

I was under the impression that rape is less about sex than it is about power. Not sure if castration would solve that.

Welp rape doesnt always happen with penises. You should fix their brain

In principle yes.

However, it would never fly legally. It would be a giant mess when you wrongly convict someone.

The immediate, incorrect assumption that every rapist or pedophile has a penis

No. That's not humane.

And what about women who rape people?

It depends on the context. But studies show it's often for both and we all know the manhood is the source of every man's pride, so castration would effectively hit 2 birds with one stone.

I don't believe bodily mutilation is a good form of punsishment in any scenario, so no.

women can get castrated too

YES, as long as there's concrete evidence that they did the crime, and if they were wrongfully convicted then... one less breeder

yes tbh

Yes.

Jail is sufficient. Just make it less glam.

Yes.