Quote:
Originally posted by Red
Let me explain why I think this isn't exactly a great idea...
I'm not going to say that it's a bad idea because it's obvious who will be #1 or top five. Being "obvious" doesn't necessarily mean "bad". One BIG problem this would have, though, is that people will not be unbiased. No one will list what they feel are ATRL's top artists. They will just list their favorites, and we'd wind up getting a list based on personal preference, especially based on what's hot right now, and not on overall impact of the forum over the years, as it should be.
Case in point, in my opinion, it's a guarantee that Ciara will be top five. With that in mind, let's say the other four are Britney, Beyonce, Rihanna and GaGa. Let's throw personal preference out the window and let me ask you this question: Can you really tell me that Ciara has had more of an impact on ATRL over the last ten years than Aguilera?
|
I agree but than again, Raven should be Top 10 AT LEAST and I'm not sure it's any better.
Britney is the one that actually had the most impact in the whole 1 and something years I was a member, endless threads, Circus leak party, putting ATRL down alot, every piece of news about her made its way to some kind of section in threads that only grow larger and larger.
There are def' more artists that were close but I don't think that the Top spot belongs to someone else.
.