Ok, so im kind of sure about my theory because im sure Piper set everything up. That's not the mother of Brandon james, Piper hired her to throw Emma off and make Kieran suspicious.

I think it would be awesome if Piper and Brandon are the killers. Brandon, being the main killer and Piper the helper. Piper was to be in the family, she wants Emma and her mom to love her. But also seeks revenge for not being a part of their lives. Brandon was never killed, he managed to escape. And found Piper and forged a relationship with her. So she know follows his orders.

Piper is the reveal in the finale. But its not revealed that she is helping someone else. Just when she is going to speak about Brandon she dies. Emma thinks its over, the killer is gone. But Brandon comes back for season 2, to finish what he started all those years ago. Since we were introduced with the Brandon killings and everything started because of him, it would makes sense that it ends with him. He is the main killer, and is not revealed until Season 2.

A I Know What You Did last Summer/Harper's Island teas

Y'all seem so invested in solving the mystery..

I'm binge-watching the show today. Don't expect me to write a report on the suspected killers though. Da fuq.

Interesting theory ... I like it

well, they made him out to be a killer. So it would make sense that if he DID survive, he would want to murder everyone for making him out to be a monster when he's not.

Creators said that one of the killers appeared in the first episode

Piper

Like, duh. Everyone appeared in the first episode. This is SCREAM. Of course one of those is the killer and not a random

Ever heard of incest?

Well yeah, but I don't see a problem with it being in a show? I mean, it's not like it's ~promoting~ incest or whatever.

!! This is not pretty little liars

Why do I have a feeling that Piper is the killer? and btw Mr Branson is so ****ing cute

Okay, so yeah, it'll be probably Audrey . At least I guess so. Maybe Piper too, but I don't know.

I just watched Scream 1 tonight. After all these years, it still feels fresh and never boring to watch. I kinda wish Scream TV was on Netflix or a channel like FX. The quality of the show would be better and there would be some swearing too! And an awesome chase scene too. I can't believe we haven't had one yet on the show... The closest would be when the killer went after Riley and Emma in the bowling alley. The season finale better serve.

As a PLL fan and Scream film series fan, I feel that the killers are more than one. Rather we find out both killers next week or not will be seen I guess.

But my theory is that Piper is the daughter. She even told Emma her dad died when she was too young to remember. I don't know the ages, but isn't Kieran the same age/close as Emma? Meaning the 1st born has to be older, right? So I really think it is Piper! Now IF Piper is the killer, then there is another (the one who pushed her and kidnapped Will). This is a toss up between Brooke, Kieran, Audrey, Noah, and Branson or someone introduced in the future. They will be revealed in S2 and that storyline/motive will be revealed.

But something is telling me that Will is still alive or some ****. Like I have this weird feeling