Quote:
Originally posted by Bríseis
I have read the op and the conclusion is that she is not a songwriter, just arranger. She almost always took a song previously written by someone else and then with her producers made minor changes to her likes, or did vocal arrangements what is common for all good vocalists without the need to give themselves a songwriting credit. Of course the songwriters praise her, they have to when they want her to further sells their stuff and know she is capable of doing it, but they almost never forget to mention that Bey came after the song was already created by them lol
And I find very interesting the percentage part... Where is the source for that? And in the light of the stealing credits accusations, it just proves that she actually gives herself a high percentage of the credits, not if she deserved them.
|
Obviously you didn't read the OP because if you did you would see that there are SEVERAL receipts of proof of her writing full songs, changing lyrics, reconstructing songs etc. Changing an entire melody or arrangement of a song is nor a 'minor' change either as a song isn't anything without a melody.
And what 'proof' is there that the she gives more percent than she deserves? She wrote all the lyrics to Bootylicious (you know, which is the end-all-be-all for songwriting on ATRL) yet only owns 25% of the song
arh2:
