What's with the skinny shaming omg so unnecessary. She's too skinny but she looks fine.

Her legs

This isn't skinny shaming.

Her legs are NOT normal. They are practically skeletal, especially for the height of the average model. I'm not surprised this forum thinks that this image is fine though. Any woman that gains even a little bit of weight is shamed beyond belief on here but when they look skeletal you all run to their defense.

You can't trash one side of the argument and support the other.

Women in fashion aren't even supposed to look like most "real" women, hence they are so severely chosen. She is skinny, so what? You can't claim she suffers from eating disorders. She isn't a skeleton, she is just model material. Y'all are getting delusional with this. And of course it would be an Adele stan to fume the most.

That isn't "thinner". It is anorexic.

It should not be encouraged any more than morbid obesity should be.

The irony.

And I suppose since I stan for Adele, that must mean I'm overweight. Most of you are seriously ****ed up to begin with. You claim to be anti body shaming yet it's all most of you do on here to every female celebrity.

The hypocrisy is incredible.

Whats wrong with her? I'm pretty much close to that, probably a little bigger and I dont have any eating disorders or anything but K

forgot yall are smart as hell and have medicine degrees and ****.

I never said she has a eating disorder. But most women are not that skinny naturally. Having less than 12% body fat is very unhealthy for a woman.

The modelling industry promotes an unrealistic beauty standard, by using extremely skinny models that aren't necessarily sick (many of them are though, don't fool yourself). It causes women to get eating disorders by being influenced by the media. This isn't skinny shaming. There's nothing wrong with being skinny, but there's something wrong with this beauty standard.

And you can't just say models aren't supposed to look like regular women. Tell that to all the women that get influenced by these models. The media basically creates our beauty standards.

We don't live in a society that glorifies obesity as ideal. So, all you people screaming "skinny bashing" are akin to those who like to shout "reverse racisme" and "reverse sexism" blah, blah, blah, when common sense should tell you that's not how our society works. Thin people do not experience hiring and job discrimination the way obese/overweight people do. Thin people do not struggle for media represenation, the way obese/overweight people do, nor are thin people systemically blamed for everything from rising health care costs to global warming. It just doesn't really happen. So no, banning this YSL ad because the model was deemed too thin is not the same as fat-a-phobia. There's a happy medium in between obesity and being underweight, and that YSL ad aint it. I wouldn't be too concerned about the model, tho. She got her check and some added publicity because of the controversy. If she's passed over by future clients in favor of models with higher BMI's, then "Oh, well." That's the nature of the game she plays, but apparently, the UK aint having it.

I've seen KPOP girls with legs like that.

Yes. and they're going to do it too.

Just like they add the "Smoking Kills" on anything related to smoke and helplines for gambling on any gambling adds.

Well I think caring about the safety of young people through promoting positive, realistic body images is more important than caring about this supposed 'nanny state'. But maybe that's me.

I disagree. Ban this ad, what's next? Bans of all kinds, soon there's no free expression left.

I'm inclined to agree with this decision. Regardless of whether the model actually has an eating disorder it promotes a body type that, to most, is practically impossible to attain without one.

Not OK.

Whilst there does need to be regulation to make sure ads are featuring girls of all sizes, this is just as bad as saying Tess Holiday shouldn't be allowed to model.

Why are people supporting this injustice?

Thin is in, get with it!

It doesn't matter what it supposedly "promotes", it's an artistic photo. Are they going to ban violent movies and video games because it "promotes" violence?

She might not have an eating disorder but there's no denying that she has health risks because of her weight. She looks around the same weight as me and she's definitely taller. I'd like to see what her BMI is because mine is 15.2. I don't have an eating disorder either. But doctors are always concerned about my weight and I have some bad health issues associated with being thin. The point is even if she may be healthy, she's easily at risk to be unhealthy due to her weight.

And I also don't know what to think about banning the ad. I definitely think it portrays a bad image to women, but I also think it's unfair to the model. W/e.