Wait I thought Coven sucked and ruined the series? Now this "amazing" new show is being based on it
Coven was fantastic except for the last 2 episodes. Freak Show really ruined American Horror Story.
But since you kept saying "It doesn't matter what the quality of AHS is! Gaga's on it and it'll have millions of viewers!", I guess we'll just wait and see SQ's ratings.
So, you're comparing the streams of a single that's literally 10 years old to one today?
Gag stans really are the pits.
esp. considering it was about Mariah, not Gaga speaking of worldwide #1s, Madonna had gotten and was getting far more than Gaga 6 years into her career...
Freak Show wasn't even that bad. What was so tarnishing about it? Emma Roberts' character?
All of it
The lack of a central plot
The horrid misuse of good actors (Kathy Bates & Frances Conroy)
The TRAGIC writing
The fact that they shoehorned Neil Patrick Harris into 2 episodes and made him the focus of those two episodes despite being so close to the end of the season
The ****** development of literally everyone
Everyone being terrible in their roles (Yes, that includes Emma!)
he's literally 3 years from her age range 
Now this "amazing" new show is being based on it 
