Added TheLament to the OP, bringing our total number of participants up to 50!

Trying to decide whether the art for Glitter or MCIIY is worse

MCIIY is almost endearing in its campy photoshopped realness.
Glitter...accurately represents the music imo

Glitter dahhling.

WAIT I forgot MIAM Target exclusive version. The one where someone took the half of the Charmbracelet face that wasn't covered, mirrored it, and blended it to match almost identically

I still don't believe that urban legend! The eyebrow is different!

Yeeess!!

wow that is amazing, is this like the biggest Discography rate ever on atrl?

I just wanna thank u for doing all this, it gotta take a lot of work to manage all this... and the mess that will start with the results ... I can't wait

Charmbracelet done

Average = 6.2

I don't know what the highest number of participants has been, but I know the biggest ever rate had like 220 pages I think? I think we'll pass that since every song requires 1 post

For sure, we'll have like 10+ responses for each song (at least that's what I hope)

I'll have my rate in ASAP.

Still getting familiar with a LOT of her discography so i'll have to relisten some albums.

Emancipation of mimi done.

Average = 7.8

Even just one song per page
Maybe we can reach 500 pages when everything is done. Especially if the rate is as messy as advertised. The lambs are gonna blow up.

My problem with some of the Glitter tracks is that you can barely even tell Mariah is on them

The rappers/guests take up too much of the song.

But that's OK when her chorus/hook is so good And Want You is split evenly

We gotta do it!

This is clearly a mistake. Are you heavily medicated at the moment?

I should have been less generous with my rates... :/

The fact that Charmie and Glitter got an average of at least 8 from me and most of my rates were 9s and 10s.

We welcome all high scores for Glitter, and reject the ones for Chamrbracelet.