|
Discussion: Burying the hatchet: Lady Gaga and Madonna
Member Since: 10/14/2008
Posts: 9,686
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Erik
I think everyone should love one another. For we must join together in harmony to defeat the greatest evil of all: Katy Perry.
|

|
|
|
Member Since: 4/4/2014
Posts: 13,402
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mariano
Monsters don't really care about that and they hardly attack anyone.. defensive, yes a lot, but that's not a bad thing.
The important thing is that Lady Gaga was immediately labeled Madonna's rival. Why ? Britney wasn't labelled The new Queen of Pop, she was labeled The princess of pop, whereas Gaga was labelled the new Queen of Pop from the moment she became huge and was portrayed by ALL MEDIA as Madonna's rival. Only 2 years vs. Madonna's 30 years, yet Gaga was portrayed as Madonna's rival and the GP see her as the new queen of pop, including people in real life who has told me "Gaga surpassed Madonna, right? " and I am like "Where did you hear that  "
This is the most important thing and this picture proves it.
When has Madonna went on a live show "fighting" with a new star as if they are her rival ?
Y'all can say whatever you want, but Madonna has never, ever been affected by anyone like she was affected by Gaga. And the simple fact that Madonna's manager was asked "How do you discover a new Madonna " in the sense of being the biggest thing on earth + having acclaim, touring and selling records all at once and her manger was like "Ask Troy Carter"
We all know why this "war" will never end. Madonna fans have never acted like that against any other artist, I wonder why
And even tho all the comparisons between Gaga and Madonna, they are super different and that's the thing that scares Madonna and her fans the most.
So yeah. People on ATRL can keep living in their own buble, I have friends who don't like pop and only listen to Snoop Dog and **** like that and they've been like "Gaga is more successful than Madonna" which of course is utter BS, but it's still an impression they have. And that's the reason for the stan wars.
Just wanted to make it clear  Madonna was trying to hop on the "Gaga wave" in 2010, but then Gaga just became too big, Gaga was no longer a tool for Madonna, Gaga was a weapon, hence why Madonna became so vile in 2011.
When has Madonna given someone so much attention, peforming their song every single night at their smash tour ? Never. All of this is for a reason and the reason is not because Gaga copied Madonna. Artists have copied artists for decades, including Madonna being copied by others and her copying others. This is not it, it's not the reason, the only reason is as I already said - Lady Gaga just came in the right moment, with the right music, with the enormeous talent etc. and she is the biggest threat Madonna has ever seen, and if she was OVER, we wouldn't have been in this thread.
Edit:
in4b someone says "the essay" this won't even get an F, so don't use it as a template !
|

|
|
|
Member Since: 3/6/2014
Posts: 13,097
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mariano
Monsters don't really care about that and they hardly attack anyone.. defensive, yes a lot, but that's not a bad thing.
The important thing is that Lady Gaga was immediately labeled Madonna's rival. Why ? Britney wasn't labelled The new Queen of Pop, she was labeled The princess of pop, whereas Gaga was labelled the new Queen of Pop from the moment she became huge and was portrayed by ALL MEDIA as Madonna's rival. Only 2 years vs. Madonna's 30 years, yet Gaga was portrayed as Madonna's rival and the GP see her as the new queen of pop, including people in real life who has told me "Gaga surpassed Madonna, right? " and I am like "Where did you hear that  "
This is the most important thing and this picture proves it.
When has Madonna went on a live show "fighting" with a new star as if they are her rival ?
Y'all can say whatever you want, but Madonna has never, ever been affected by anyone like she was affected by Gaga. And the simple fact that Madonna's manager was asked "How do you discover a new Madonna " in the sense of being the biggest thing on earth + having acclaim, touring and selling records all at once and her manger was like "Ask Troy Carter"
We all know why this "war" will never end. Madonna fans have never acted like that against any other artist, I wonder why
And even tho all the comparisons between Gaga and Madonna, they are super different and that's the thing that scares Madonna and her fans the most.
So yeah. People on ATRL can keep living in their own buble, I have friends who don't like pop and only listen to Snoop Dog and **** like that and they've been like "Gaga is more successful than Madonna" which of course is utter BS, but it's still an impression they have. And that's the reason for the stan wars.
Just wanted to make it clear  Madonna was trying to hop on the "Gaga wave" in 2010, but then Gaga just became too big, Gaga was no longer a tool for Madonna, Gaga was a weapon, hence why Madonna became so vile in 2011.
When has Madonna given someone so much attention, peforming their song every single night at their smash tour ? Never. All of this is for a reason and the reason is not because Gaga copied Madonna. Artists have copied artists for decades, including Madonna being copied by others and her copying others. This is not it, it's not the reason, the only reason is as I already said - Lady Gaga just came in the right moment, with the right music, with the enormeous talent etc. and she is the biggest threat Madonna has ever seen, and if she was OVER, we wouldn't have been in this thread.
Edit:
in4b someone says "the essay" this won't even get an F, so don't use it as a template !
|
Do you have this pre-saved to a Microsoft Word document or do you type them on the spot?
OT: No.
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 31,020
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mariano
Monsters don't really care about that and they hardly attack anyone.. defensive, yes a lot, but that's not a bad thing.
The important thing is that Lady Gaga was immediately labeled Madonna's rival. Why ? Britney wasn't labelled The new Queen of Pop, she was labeled The princess of pop, whereas Gaga was labelled the new Queen of Pop from the moment she became huge and was portrayed by ALL MEDIA as Madonna's rival. Only 2 years vs. Madonna's 30 years, yet Gaga was portrayed as Madonna's rival and the GP see her as the new queen of pop, including people in real life who has told me "Gaga surpassed Madonna, right? " and I am like "Where did you hear that  "
This is the most important thing and this picture proves it.
When has Madonna went on a live show "fighting" with a new star as if they are her rival ?
Y'all can say whatever you want, but Madonna has never, ever been affected by anyone like she was affected by Gaga. And the simple fact that Madonna's manager was asked "How do you discover a new Madonna " in the sense of being the biggest thing on earth + having acclaim, touring and selling records all at once and her manger was like "Ask Troy Carter"
We all know why this "war" will never end. Madonna fans have never acted like that against any other artist, I wonder why
And even tho all the comparisons between Gaga and Madonna, they are super different and that's the thing that scares Madonna and her fans the most.
So yeah. People on ATRL can keep living in their own buble, I have friends who don't like pop and only listen to Snoop Dog and **** like that and they've been like "Gaga is more successful than Madonna" which of course is utter BS, but it's still an impression they have. And that's the reason for the stan wars.
Just wanted to make it clear  Madonna was trying to hop on the "Gaga wave" in 2010, but then Gaga just became too big, Gaga was no longer a tool for Madonna, Gaga was a weapon, hence why Madonna became so vile in 2011.
When has Madonna given someone so much attention, peforming their song every single night at their smash tour ? Never. All of this is for a reason and the reason is not because Gaga copied Madonna. Artists have copied artists for decades, including Madonna being copied by others and her copying others. This is not it, it's not the reason, the only reason is as I already said - Lady Gaga just came in the right moment, with the right music, with the enormeous talent etc. and she is the biggest threat Madonna has ever seen, and if she was OVER, we wouldn't have been in this thread.
Edit:
in4b someone says "the essay" this won't even get an F, so don't use it as a template !
|
how long were you waiting for a thread to copy and paste that 
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/28/2012
Posts: 34,863
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mariano
Monsters don't really care about that and they hardly attack anyone.. defensive, yes a lot, but that's not a bad thing.
The important thing is that Lady Gaga was immediately labeled Madonna's rival. Why ? Britney wasn't labelled The new Queen of Pop, she was labeled The princess of pop, whereas Gaga was labelled the new Queen of Pop from the moment she became huge and was portrayed by ALL MEDIA as Madonna's rival. Only 2 years vs. Madonna's 30 years, yet Gaga was portrayed as Madonna's rival and the GP see her as the new queen of pop, including people in real life who has told me "Gaga surpassed Madonna, right? " and I am like "Where did you hear that  "
This is the most important thing and this picture proves it.
When has Madonna went on a live show "fighting" with a new star as if they are her rival ?
Y'all can say whatever you want, but Madonna has never, ever been affected by anyone like she was affected by Gaga. And the simple fact that Madonna's manager was asked "How do you discover a new Madonna " in the sense of being the biggest thing on earth + having acclaim, touring and selling records all at once and her manger was like "Ask Troy Carter"
We all know why this "war" will never end. Madonna fans have never acted like that against any other artist, I wonder why
And even tho all the comparisons between Gaga and Madonna, they are super different and that's the thing that scares Madonna and her fans the most.
So yeah. People on ATRL can keep living in their own buble, I have friends who don't like pop and only listen to Snoop Dog and **** like that and they've been like "Gaga is more successful than Madonna" which of course is utter BS, but it's still an impression they have. And that's the reason for the stan wars.
Just wanted to make it clear  Madonna was trying to hop on the "Gaga wave" in 2010, but then Gaga just became too big, Gaga was no longer a tool for Madonna, Gaga was a weapon, hence why Madonna became so vile in 2011.
When has Madonna given someone so much attention, peforming their song every single night at their smash tour ? Never. All of this is for a reason and the reason is not because Gaga copied Madonna. Artists have copied artists for decades, including Madonna being copied by others and her copying others. This is not it, it's not the reason, the only reason is as I already said - Lady Gaga just came in the right moment, with the right music, with the enormeous talent etc. and she is the biggest threat Madonna has ever seen, and if she was OVER, we wouldn't have been in this thread.
Edit:
in4b someone says "the essay" this won't even get an F, so don't use it as a template !
|
Good
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/4/2014
Posts: 13,402
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Nialler
how long were you waiting for a thread to copy and paste that 
|
Good lord 
-
OT: I don't think so
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 25,504
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KatyLegendperry
Do you have this pre-saved to a Microsoft Word document or do you type them on the spot?
OT: No.
|
I understand it must seem pretty complicated to you, KatyLegendperry, but I actually typed it in like a minute
Monsters and Gaga have clearly moved on. Obviously we are going to defend our fav on a pop music forum, it's normal.
Quote:
Originally posted by ultraviolento
Good lord 
-
OT: I don't think so
|
he dragged me for filth right ? 
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 42,704
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mariano
I understand it must seem pretty complicated to you, KatyLegendperry, but I actually typed it in like a minute
Monsters and Gaga have clearly moved on. Obviously we are going to defend our fav on a pop music forum, it's normal.
he dragged me for filth right ? 
|
The clapback
You spilled some scalding hot tea in that post
_
Just look at the second post made by a medonster.
Shows how much your fanbase hates Gaga for no reason at all.
Don't think it's going to work
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/6/2014
Posts: 10,308
|
I honestly do not care about Madonna which would be the reason why I barely post into any of those threads.
I'm here for Gaga and many Madonna fans here will say they don't care about her but why is it that Madonnation has a subsection just for Gaga, why is it Pawsdown exists and threads here are always flooded by the same people co-signing a "drag" with an  or
If you truly don't care, don't click, don't read and most certainly do not reply.
Anyhow if anyone from any of the 2 fanbases wants to burry a hatchet, that would be a very healthy move and if not, well continue to be pressed for whatever reason.
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/7/2011
Posts: 41,996
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mariano
I understand it must seem pretty complicated to you, KatyLegendperry, but I actually typed it in like a minute
Monsters and Gaga have clearly moved on. Obviously we are going to defend our fav on a pop music forum, it's normal.
he dragged me for filth right ? 
|
"Monsters and Gaga have clearly moved on" *writes an unnecessary essay*
--
Good luck with that!
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/14/2011
Posts: 48,397
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mariano
Monsters don't really care about that and they hardly attack anyone.. defensive, yes a lot, but that's not a bad thing.
|
Yeah right
Anyway making peace between stans is unrealistic.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/5/2011
Posts: 30,130
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mariano
Monsters don't really care about that and they hardly attack anyone.. defensive, yes a lot, but that's not a bad thing.
The important thing is that Lady Gaga was immediately labeled Madonna's rival. Why ? Britney wasn't labelled The new Queen of Pop, she was labeled The princess of pop, whereas Gaga was labelled the new Queen of Pop from the moment she became huge and was portrayed by ALL MEDIA as Madonna's rival. Only 2 years vs. Madonna's 30 years, yet Gaga was portrayed as Madonna's rival and the GP see her as the new queen of pop, including people in real life who has told me "Gaga surpassed Madonna, right? " and I am like "Where did you hear that  "
This is the most important thing and this picture proves it.
When has Madonna went on a live show "fighting" with a new star as if they are her rival ?
Y'all can say whatever you want, but Madonna has never, ever been affected by anyone like she was affected by Gaga. And the simple fact that Madonna's manager was asked "How do you discover a new Madonna " in the sense of being the biggest thing on earth + having acclaim, touring and selling records all at once and her manger was like "Ask Troy Carter"
We all know why this "war" will never end. Madonna fans have never acted like that against any other artist, I wonder why
And even tho all the comparisons between Gaga and Madonna, they are super different and that's the thing that scares Madonna and her fans the most.
So yeah. People on ATRL can keep living in their own buble, I have friends who don't like pop and only listen to Snoop Dog and **** like that and they've been like "Gaga is more successful than Madonna" which of course is utter BS, but it's still an impression they have. And that's the reason for the stan wars.
Just wanted to make it clear  Madonna was trying to hop on the "Gaga wave" in 2010, but then Gaga just became too big, Gaga was no longer a tool for Madonna, Gaga was a weapon, hence why Madonna became so vile in 2011.
When has Madonna given someone so much attention, peforming their song every single night at their smash tour ? Never. All of this is for a reason and the reason is not because Gaga copied Madonna. Artists have copied artists for decades, including Madonna being copied by others and her copying others. This is not it, it's not the reason, the only reason is as I already said - Lady Gaga just came in the right moment, with the right music, with the enormeous talent etc. and she is the biggest threat Madonna has ever seen, and if she was OVER, we wouldn't have been in this thread.
Edit:
in4b someone says "the essay" this won't even get an F, so don't use it as a template !
|

|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 25,504
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starstruck.
"Monsters and Gaga have clearly moved on" *writes an unnecessary essay*
--
Good luck with that!
|
nowhere in my "essay" did I say anything bad about Madonna or her fans, it was an explanation of why the stan wars will never stop and why there are stan wars in the first place.
How often do you see monsters posting in Madonna threads ? How often do you see Madonna fans posting in Gaga threads ?
The difference is that Gaga is active right now and has a younger fanbase and a lot more people from that fanbase are online, so more Gaga fans posting in Madonna threads would make more sense, YET it's still more Madonna fans posting on Gaga threads.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/6/2014
Posts: 2,264
|
Quote:
Originally posted by GypsyLife
I honestly do not care about Madonna which would be the reason why I barely post into any of those threads.
I'm here for Gaga and many Madonna fans here will say they don't care about her but why is it that Madonnation has a subsection just for Gaga, why is it Pawsdown exists and threads here are always flooded by the same people co-signing a "drag" with an  or
If you truly don't care, don't click, don't read and most certainly do not reply.
Anyhow if anyone from any of the 2 fanbases wants to burry a hatchet, that would be a very healthy move and if not, well continue to be pressed for whatever reason.
|
then dont read if you dont care
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/28/2012
Posts: 37,654
|
Who gives a **** about what other people think, say, or do?  I'll always love both Madonna & Gaga, and could honestly care less about who else does or doesn't.

|
|
|
Member Since: 4/28/2012
Posts: 37,654
|
Mess @ me replying to this thread minutes before the pictures

|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 10,987
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mariano
Monsters don't really care about that and they hardly attack anyone.. defensive, yes a lot, but that's not a bad thing.
The important thing is that Lady Gaga was immediately labeled Madonna's rival. Why ? Britney wasn't labelled The new Queen of Pop, she was labeled The princess of pop, whereas Gaga was labelled the new Queen of Pop from the moment she became huge and was portrayed by ALL MEDIA as Madonna's rival. Only 2 years vs. Madonna's 30 years, yet Gaga was portrayed as Madonna's rival and the GP see her as the new queen of pop, including people in real life who has told me "Gaga surpassed Madonna, right? " and I am like "Where did you hear that  "
This is the most important thing and this picture proves it.
When has Madonna went on a live show "fighting" with a new star as if they are her rival ?
Y'all can say whatever you want, but Madonna has never, ever been affected by anyone like she was affected by Gaga. And the simple fact that Madonna's manager was asked "How do you discover a new Madonna " in the sense of being the biggest thing on earth + having acclaim, touring and selling records all at once and her manger was like "Ask Troy Carter"
We all know why this "war" will never end. Madonna fans have never acted like that against any other artist, I wonder why
And even tho all the comparisons between Gaga and Madonna, they are super different and that's the thing that scares Madonna and her fans the most.
So yeah. People on ATRL can keep living in their own buble, I have friends who don't like pop and only listen to Snoop Dog and **** like that and they've been like "Gaga is more successful than Madonna" which of course is utter BS, but it's still an impression they have. And that's the reason for the stan wars.
Just wanted to make it clear  Madonna was trying to hop on the "Gaga wave" in 2010, but then Gaga just became too big, Gaga was no longer a tool for Madonna, Gaga was a weapon, hence why Madonna became so vile in 2011.
When has Madonna given someone so much attention, peforming their song every single night at their smash tour ? Never. All of this is for a reason and the reason is not because Gaga copied Madonna. Artists have copied artists for decades, including Madonna being copied by others and her copying others. This is not it, it's not the reason, the only reason is as I already said - Lady Gaga just came in the right moment, with the right music, with the enormeous talent etc. and she is the biggest threat Madonna has ever seen, and if she was OVER, we wouldn't have been in this thread.
Edit:
in4b someone says "the essay" this won't even get an F, so don't use it as a template !
|
Yaas sis give us that college level essay lol

|
|
|
Member Since: 9/1/2013
Posts: 17,161
|
ive been doing it for 1 month,so yes
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/6/2014
Posts: 10,308
|
So how many have burried the hatchet now hmm? 
|
|
|
|
|