Discussion: Icons Go Commercial: WINNER REVEALED - Page 15

Superiore

A damn mess at Angels Cry being one of the first Mimi songs to leave

I knew you all would've dragged poor Madge!

alkralkra

Angels Cry is the worst song on the album. Still better than most of the other albums though.

minho

Superstar should have been first song out. Its up there as one of the worst songs of her entire career!

B-Day Song is actually really enjoyable. Not 10-worthy but still really good, wish it made it at least to the top 40.

minho

Angels Cry is fine but the Ne-Yo remix is unnecessary and stupid. He really knows how to ruin everything he touches

feelslikeadream

Quote:

Originally posted by Superiore

A damn mess at Angels Cry being one of the first Mimi songs to leave

I knew you all would've dragged poor Madge!

That was just the Ne-Yo remix though.

Quicksand

Quote:

Originally posted by GarageGlamorous

I feel like IFU should have been higher than second to last, and Best Friend was cute at the MDNA Tour as an interlude but whatever. The actual song is eh.

No meltdowns yet. Those will come if Girl Gone Wild leaves before at least the Top 20. One of my few tens, and deserved to at least chart on the Hot 100 if nothing else.

Best Friend got a 9.5 from me. I think it's great

Quote:

Originally posted by Superiore

A damn mess at Angels Cry being one of the first Mimi songs to leave

I knew you all would've dragged poor Madge!

There's still Angel (The Prelude) and the solo version of Angels Cry left!

Superiore

Omg I messed up my Angels Cry scores

I just checked the PM

Too late, I guess

conatus

KillingYourCareer

I ****ed Up is a masterpiece

alkralkra

H.A.T.E.U. Candy Bling and Ribbon, one-two-three PUNCH!

Mayweather could never.

minho

Even though I believe MDNA > American Life, MDNA has some of the worst songs of her entire career for me.

Gang Bang, Girl Gone Wild, Superstar, I ****ed Up, are all atrocious. Poor it.

materialboy

Quote:

Originally posted by lovesong

Even though I believe MDNA > American Life, MDNA has some of the worst songs of her entire career for me.

Gang Bang, Girl Gone Wild, Superstar, I ****ed Up, are all atrocious. Poor it.

Nothing Fails>>>>>>>>>MDNA

GGW and GB are amazing

feelslikeadream

Quote:

Originally posted by materialboy

Nothing Fails>>>>>>>>>MDNA

GGW ~~and GB are~~ is amazing

Agree completely.

minho

Nothing Fails

I'm A Sinner, B-Day Song, I'm Addicted, Give Me All Your Luvin' >>> 90% of that uneventful tryhard mess

I'd much rather take Madonna having fun and not taking her self seriously than letting her ego get in the way of her ability to create pop music.

minho

Because i'm bored...

American Life ratings

Nothing is deserving of 1 or 0 but everything is below average for me.

Subomie

It's all 0s except Nobody Knows Me (5) Die Another Day (6) and Easy Ride (8).

materialboy

Easy **** getting a 10 and the closest we have got to LAP-Nothing Fails receives a 3 ?

American Life - 8
Hollywood - 10
I'm So Stupid - 5
Love Profusion - 8
Nobody Knows Me - 10
Nothing Fails - 10
Intervention - 7
X-Static Process - 6
Mother And Father - 10
Die Another Day - 10
Easy Ride - 5

Hollywood is better than Erotica (album) because its lyrics clearly describe LA
Mother and Father is an amazing where she sings about her childhood and its really emotional

Nobody Knows Me >>>>>>

I dared and i did it

sorry for off-topic

minho

I'm not religious
But I feel so moved
Makes me want to pray
Pray you'll always be here

This is NOT what the 'Queen of Pop' should be delivering.

Edit: Erm... same applies to Gang Bang/GGW!

Quicksand

I may be able to squeeze in a few songs today but if I can't, I'll do a big update tomorrow!

Subomie

American Travesty having 10s

Mother and Father being one of them

Nothing Fails being mentioned in the same breath as Like A Prayer

AL stans are funny, delusional but funny.