She is hardly the best performer of all-time

Performing is not just doing a rehearsed routine. But ATRL is mostly pop-only fans, who were raised on highly choreographed and American Idol style performances, where immaculate, pitch perfect vocals (even if they're devoid of any real passion or if what they're singing is totally superficial or mediocre) are the only representation of talent.

because people have different opinions?

Lol here comes the pretentious "I stan for old folks so I know better".

You have to love it. This thread should be closed, it'll border on flamebait territory in a minute.
And I love how "Beyoncé is an excellent vocalist but not the best, an excellent entertainer but not the best" so the praise is not warranted. So I guess since Mariah and Whitney were not the best vocalists EVER and didn't make music as good as Aretha and didn't bother dancing, they are overrated too. Funny how it's always Britneys and Jlo's fans too.

And my opinion that Aretha is the best female musician to has ever lived must be an overration too because she wasn't as involved as some other artist from that time who wrote every single of his lyrics and played every one of his notes. fffff

Because she is, her music isn't the best and there are better performers like P!nk, Britney Spears (even if she doesn't sing live), Katy Perry (even if she "can't" sing, Lady Gaga, etc

She's a good performer but I find her performances kind of boring.

YIKES

Whew, I forgot how bloody amazing that performance was.

I've never understood this. But I guess I'm secure in myself enough not to be hurt by near perfection.

Talented but the actual quality in songs is lacking.

I do know better though lol
And what you've said has nothing to do with what I've said nor with my respond to that guy.
Mariah and Whitney aren't overrated though,sometimes they are underrated by some ppl

I love Aretha F

Same goes for you bb.
And with this post you've proved what ppl were saying,without them even trying it hahah

No performer today can see Beyonce on STAGE period.

I can't at this J No stan .

Thank You!!

Her vocals are good but her dancing skills are overated.

This

Yikes

Katy Perry a better performer than Beyonce.

I love how ya'll aren't able to "defend" your fave,without trashing other artists and other ppl (who most of the time have nothing to do with discussion) hahah

A f**king MESS


Stan for 2 untalented birds.