Glee Song Rate Brainstorming List
Season 11. "On My Own" (Pilot) - Rachel Berry
"Sit Down, You're Rocking The Boat (Extended Version)" (Pilot) - Artie Abrams with Kurt Hummel and Tina Cohen-Chang
"Can't Fight This Feeling" (Pilot) - Finn Hudson
"Leaving On A Jet Plane" (Pilot) - Will Schuester
"Don't Stop Believin'" (Pilot) - Finn Hudson & Rachel Berry
"Gold Digger" (Showmance) - Will Schuester with Artie Abrams and Mercedes Jones
"Push It" (Showmance) - Artie Abrams, Finn Hudson, Mercedes Jones, Rachel Berry and Tina Cohen-Chang
"I Say A Little Prayer" (Showmance) - Quinn Fabray
"Take A Bow" (Showmance) - Rachel Berry with Mercedes Jones & Tina Cohen-Chang
"Bust Your Windows" (Acafellas) - Merecedes Jones
"I Wanna Sex You Up" (Acafellas) - Will Shuester, Finn Hudson, Puck and Sandy Ryerson (As The Acafellas)
"Taking Chances" (Preggars) - Rachel Berry
"Maybe This Time" (The Rhodes Not Taken) - April Rhodes & Rachel Berry
"Alone" (The Rhodes Not Taken) - April Rhodes & Will Shuester
"Last Name" (The Rhodes Not Taken) - April Rhodes
"Somebody To Love" (The Rhodes Not Taken) - Finn Hudson, Rachel Berry, Artie Abrams & Mercedes Jones
"It's My Life/Confessions Part II" (Vitamin D) - Finn Hudson, Artie Abrams, and Puck
"Halo/Walking On Sunshine" (Vitamin D) - Rachel Berry & Mercedes Jones
"Hate On Me" (Throwdown) - Mercedes Jones with Tina Cohen-Chang
"Ride wit Me" (Throwdown) - Glee Cast
"No Air" (Throwdown) - Rachel Berry & Finn Hudson
"You Keep Me Hangin' On" (Throwdown) - Quinn Fabray
"Keep Holding On" (Throwdown) - Finn Hudson & Rachel Berry
"Bust A Move" (Mash Up) - Will Schuester with Quinn Fabray and Mercedes Jones
"Thong Song" (Mash Up) - Will Schuester
"Sweet Caroline" (Mash Up) - Puck
"I Could Have Danced All Night" (Mash Up) - Emma Pillsbury
"Dancing With Myself" (Wheels) - Artie Abrams
"Defying Gravity (Rachel Solo)" (Wheels) - Rachel Berry
"Defying Gravity (Kurt Solo)" (Wheels) - Kurt Hummel
"Proud Mary" (Wheels) - Artie Abrams, Mercedes Jones and Tina Cohen-Chang with Finn Hudson
"Endless Love" (Ballad) - Will Schuester & Rachel Berry
"I'll Stand By You" (Ballad) - Finn Hudson
"Don't Stand So Close to Me/Young Girl" (Ballad) - Will Schuester
"Crush" (Ballad) - Rachel Berry
(You're) Having My Baby (Ballad) - Finn Hudson
"Lean On Me" (Ballad) - Mercedes Jones & Artie Abrams with Tina Cohen-Chang
"Bootylicous" (Hairography) - Shadonda and Aphasia of The Jane Adams Academy
Hair/Crazy In Love (Hairography) - Mercedes Jones & Artie Abrams
"Imagine" (Album Version) (Hairography) - Mercedes Jones, Artie Abrams, Finn Hudson and Rachel Berry
"True Colours" (Hairography) - Tina Cohen-Chang
"Smile (Lily Allen Cover)" (Mattress) - Rachel Berry and Finn Hudson
"Smile (Charlie Chaplin)" (Mattress) - Rachel Berry, Merecedes Jones, Finn Hudson and Artie Abrams
"Jump" (Mattress) - Artie Abrams, Finn Hudson, Rachel Berry and Mercedes Jones with Quinn Fabray, Tina Cohen-Chang, Puck and Kurt Hummel
"And I'm Telling You I'm Not Going" (Sectionals) - Mercedes Jones
"Don't Rain On My Parade (Rachel's Version) (Sectionals) - Rachel Berry
"You Can't Always Get What You Want" (Sectionals) - Finn Hudson, Rachel Berry, Artie Abrams and Mercedes Jones
"My Life Would Suck Without You" (Sectionals) - Rachel Berry, Tina Cohen-Chang and Finn Hudson
"Gives You Hell" (Hell-O) - Rachel Berry
"Hello, I Love You" (Hell-O) - Finn Hudson
Highway To Hell" (Hell-O) - Jesse St. James with Unknown Female
"Hello, Goodbye" (Hell-O) - Finn Hudson, Rachel Berry and Merecedes Jones
"Hello" (Hell-O) - Jesse St James & Rachel Berry
"Express Yourself" (The Power Of Madonna) - Rachel Berry, Mercedes Jones, Tina Cohen-Chang, Quinn Fabray and Santana Lopez
"Burnin' Up" (Cut From The Power Of Madonna; included on iTunes version of EP) - Jessie James with Vocal Adrenaline Girl
"Bordeline/Open Your Heart" (Power Of Madonna) - Finn Hudson & Rachel Berry
"Vogue" (Power Of Madonna) - Sue Sylvester
"Like A Virgin" (Power Of Madonna) - Will Schuester, Emma Pillsbury, Rachel Berry, Jesse St. James, Santana Lopez & Finn Hudson
"4 Minutes" (Power Of Madonna) - Mercedes Jones & Kurt Hummel
"What It Feels Like For A Girl" (Power Of Madonna) - Artie Abrams, Finn Hudson, Puck with Kurt Hummel
"Like A Prayer" (Power Of Madonna) - Rachel Berry, Mercedes Jones, Jessie St James, Finn Hudson and Kurt Hummel
"Fire" (Home) - Will Schuester & April Rhodes
"A House Is Not A Home (Episode Version)" (Home) - Kurt Hummel & Finn Hudson
"One Less Bell to Answer/A House Is Not a Home" (Home) - April Rhodes & Will Schuester
"Beautiful" (Home) - Mercedes Jones
"Home (April Rhodes Solo)" (Home) - April Rhodes
"Ice Ice Baby" (Bad Reputation) - Will Schuester
U Can't Touch This (Bad Reputation) - Artie Abrams
Run Joey Run (Bad Reputation) - Rachel Berry, Finn Hudson, Jesse St James and Puck
"Physical" (Bad Reputation) - Olivia Newton John & Sue Sylvester
"Total Eclipse Of The Heart" (Bad Reputation) - Rachel Berry, Jessie St James, Finn Hudson and Puck
"Jesse's Girl" (Laryngitis) - Finn Hudson
"Lady Is A Tramp" (Laryngitis) Mercedes Jones & Puck
"The Boy Is Mine" (Laryngitis) -Mercedes Jones & Santana Lopez
"Rose's Turn" (Laryngitis) - Kurt Hummel
"One" (Album Version) (Laryngitis) - Rachel Berry, Finn Hudson and Mercedes Jones
"Dream On" (Dream On) - Will Schuester & Bryan Ryan
"Safety Dance" (Dream On) - Artie Abrams with Tina Cohen-Chang
"I Dreamed A Dream" (Dream On) - Rachel Berry & Shelby Corcoran
"Dream A Little Dream" (Dream On) - Artie Abrams
"Funny Girl" (Theatricality) - Shelby Corcoran
"Bad Romance" (Theatricality) - Kurt Hummel, Merecedes Jones, Tina Cohen-Chang, Quinn Fabray & Santana Lopez
"Shout It Out Loud" (Theatricality) - Finn Hudson, Artie Abrams and Puck
"Beth" (Theatricality) - Finn Hudson & Puck
"Poker Face" Theatricality) - Rachel Berry & Shelby Cocoran
"Another One Bites The Dust" (Funk) - Jessie St James
"Tell Me Something Good" (Funk) - Will Schuester
"Loser" (Funk) - Finn Hudson, Puck, and Terri Schuester with Howard Bamboo & Sandy Ryderson
"It's A Man's Man's Man's World" (Funk) - Quinn Fabray
"Good Vibrations" (Funk) - Finn Hudson, Puck & Merecedes Jones
"Give Up The Funk" - Merecedes Jones, Finn Hudson, Artie Abrams, Tina Cohen-Chang with Kurt Hummel
"Faithfully" (Journey) - Finn Hudson & Rachel Berry
Anyway You Want It/Lovin' Touchin' Squeezin'" (Journey) - Finn Hudson, Rachel Berry, Puck, Artie Abrams, Merecedes Jones and Kurt Hummel
"Don't Stop Believin' (Regionals Version)" (Journey) - Finn Hudson, Rachel Berry, Artie Abrams, Santana Lopez, Puck, Merecedes Jones, and Kurt Hummel
"Bohemian Rhapsody" (Journey) - Jessie St. James
To Sir, With Love (Journey) - Rachel Berry, Finn, Artie Abrams, Tina Cohen-Chang, Santana Lopez and Kurt Hummel
"Somewhere Over The Rainbow" (Journey) - Will Schuester with Puck
I might remove a couple songs...but so far this is what I have for season 1. I didn't use songs such as the auditions that were in the pilot and other songs that were only performed for a couple of seconds.
I've been working on the songs for a few days so far.
But be prepared for a certain season 3 song you may not have noticed that has leaked (and later rerecorded) and a unreleased Brittany solo from Season 4 
I didn't really like the finale tbh though 
