Uh no, not at all. Natalia not only harassed and bullied the contestant, but she did it for a fictional reason that was embarrasing and made no sense. She made a complete fool of herself while also aggressively abusing a contestant.

She deserves all of this, and worse.

yes, the sexism in the industry is disgusting.

because he was commenting on their SINGING, not on how they stole someone's look (who doesn't even own it).

that's where her problem lies. Most of the time Simon is mean, it has to do with singing. Natalie was just being rude for no reason.

lol, no, don't try to pull the sexist card to make Natalia look better.

She basically went off on a tangent criticizing him for wearing a suit, and just flat out trash talking him to his face, and it wasn't related to his performance. In fact, she said she didn't want to give him feedback. 't was uncalled for.

Simon is harsh, but his comments are always about the performance at hand. He has never said something as bad as "I'm ashamed to be in your presence" "I don't want to give you my feedback", etc. He doesn't criticize the person's character unless they're being an ass.

/thread

This. Simon has a reason for what he says, and it might be brutally honest and harsh, but its about what the contestant present FOR him to judge.

Natalia's tirade came out of nowhere and had nothing to do with what the contestant was presenting for her to judge.

this tbh

Deep down, Simon does have a good heart. This is one example of him knowing when to hold back on his comments.


^By the way, shame on the producers for putting that girl through the first audition rounds and making her think she had a chance. So cruel.

She still has some cute bops ngl. Got me like