Poll: Xtina never destroyed Bey vocally?? - Page 11

Reza

Welp for once I agree with an ATRL poll. X wins again!

Havoc

Quote:

Originally posted by Crush2.0

Then how come beyonce with all her technique and perfect singing wasn't able to top Xtinas performance on the 2007 GRAMMYs. Beyonces performance wasn't memorable or praise like Xtinas. Even Christinas performance of IAMW became one of the top 3 performances of all time at the Grammys. Remember boo?

Seriously, Did you read the post?

Quote:

A singer is judged for their ability based on how their voices actually perform in live performances, studio recordings etc, not on how popular or well-received one is. So when arguing who is the better singer between Beyonce or Xtina, Receipts like The Rolling Stone List and the GP are irrelevant if you don't have anything concrete to back them up with.

Any praise of memorability that Xtina got for a performance has absolutely nothing to do with whether or nor she's a better vocalist than Bey. Especially for a god awful performance where she did was screaming and hollering out of tune. (and don't say that she wasn't, because that's literally what she was doing whether you want to realize it not)

Reza

Quote:

Originally posted by Havoc

Seriously, Did you read the post?

Any praise of memorability that Xtina got for a performance has absolutely nothing to do with whether or nor she's a better vocalist than Bey. Especially for a god awful performance where she did was screaming and hollering out of tune. (and don't say that she wasn't, because that's literally what she was doing whether you want to realize it not)

once again just because that's your opinion doesn't make it a fact.

.KUNTana

Quote:

Originally posted by Havoc

Objective? There is nothing obiective about anything you or any other Xtina fan have said in this thread. Let's talk about Objectivity:

Christina's lower register is airy and unsupported, Beyonce's is rich and full
Christina's strains on cracks severely and consistently on simple mid-belts, Beyonce's middle register is effortless and resonant.
Christina's voice thins out the higher it gets, Beyonce's voice resonates from top to bottom
Christina sings with a disconnected falsetto, Beyonce sings with a fully connected head voice
Christina has piss poor intonation; Beyonce's is damn near flawless
Christina has no vibrato above a C5, Beyonce has a natural, evenly-placed vibrato that she can utilize throughout almost her entire range.
Christina doesn't know how to control her voice, Beyonce has immaculate control over hers
Christina has very little knowledge on the strengths and weaknesses of her voice; Beyonce knows hers inside and out.
Christina's runs lack substance and often make no sense with the melody, Beyonce's runs are complex and perfectly placed within the music shes singing.
Christina can't sustain notes without either warbling the note with the jaw or gliding up to it; Beyonce could sustain notes by hitting them head on.

I know you are going to turn this around and claim "but the GP prefers XTINA!!" but guess what? The GP has absolutely nothing to do with determining vocal ability. A singer is judged for their ability based on how their voices actually perform in live performances, studio recordings etc, not on how popular or well-received one is. So when arguing who is the better singer between Beyonce or Xtina, Receipts like The Rolling Stone List and the GP are irrelevant if you don't have anything concrete to back them up with. Everything pointed out in this post can be verified by Beyonce and Xtina's performances throughout the years. This is objectivity.

Sis, have a seat.
Outside of the forums NO ONE will ever agree to Bey being better than X vocally. That's the Ki
The GP, as you so proudly like to discredit and claim don't matter; are a much larger group of people than some stan/fan base on an Internet forum. And while they might not have an insight on what a perfect vocal, note, run etc is suppose to sound like, they sure as hell have an ear and an opinion. It's always been Christina is a better singer than Beyonce. So all those flaws, imperfections that you shamelessly pointed out about Christina, has made her that bitch that still sh!t on your fav vocally to the larger crowd. That's why you girls are mad.

Crush2.0

Quote:

Originally posted by Havoc

Seriously, Did you read the post?

Any praise of memorability that Xtina got for a performance has absolutely nothing to do with whether or nor she's a better vocalist than Bey. Especially for a god awful performance where she did was screaming and hollering out of tune. (and don't say that she wasn't, because that's literally what she was doing whether you want to realize it not)

Then how come if she only screams she has the respect of real LEGENDS and they all praise her Vocals?

How come she overshadow Bey and her perfect technique with her "screams" would you care to explain.

I believe Celine over pressed stans like you. She her self thinks Legenda Equis is superior vocally than Bey.

Taemira

Quote:

Originally posted by Latch

!!!!!!!
always darkening her voice to sound ~soulful
I don't get how people consider that "emotion"
it's phony as hell

Yep. And "Emotional singing" itself is very subjective. People can't distinguish between perfect acting and actual emotion. The only thing you should care about when someone sings is how he interprets the songs. Beyoncé interprets the songs through her volume control, tone changing, and ornaments. Christina doesn't. There's only three things in her singing: pushed-down larynx in her lower and middle register, pulled-up larynx in her upper register, and self-indulgent runs that literally have nothing to do with the songs' melodies, emotions, and structures.

As Havoc preached, Christina also sucks technique-wise.

supaspaz

Flamebait thread.