Nagi No Asukara
Inuyasha
Clannad
Lovely Complex
Heavens Lost Property
Vampire Knight
Angel Beats

My "Vanilla" anime catalogue huntie

Astroboy/Bakugan/Beyblade/Captain Tsubasa/Cardcaptor Sakura/Chaotic/Crayon Shin-Chan/Cyborg Kuro-Chan/Detective Conan/Digimon/Dinosaur King/Doraemon/Dragon Ball/Duel Masters/Grimm's Fairy Tale Classics/Gundam/Hamtaro/Inuyasha/Medabots/Mirmo!/Monster Rancher/Pokémon/Ranma ½/Red Baron/Rurouni Kenshin/Sailor Moon/Saint Seiya/Shaman King/Transformers/Yu-Gi-Oh!/YuYu Hakusho/Zoids

Wow You improved I would say no to No Game No Life though and I never watched Nagi so idk about that

Dont do Death Parade like dat

Anyone suggest Madoka yet? Very short, very fast, and very good.

I recommend AoT, Claymore and Hunter x Hunter

I'm into the short, fast paced, action type anime. Some really good animes I've watched are:

Sword Art Online
Sword Art Online II
Kill la Kill
Death Note [I'm currently starting the 2nd season]

I dropped Akame Ga Kill because it got boring for me, and I finished Angel Beats! but I didn't enjoy it and I thought it was, mostly, very confusing and boring at times. There's some really good twists on Angel Beats! though, so I'd still recommend you watch it

And if you are into the funny genre of anime I'd say watch "Bludgeoning Angel Dokuro-Chan", it's really funny and sexual at times