Discussion: Are Xtina vocal abilities really that great? - Page 4

Save My Life

Her voice is FLAWLESS even after all these years. I could listen to her all day.

She is a great vocalist, she just loves to hit them long notes basically.

PopNStuff

X has said herself that she's not a trained technical singer, she sings from the heart and soul.

But every now and then, she'll practice restraint and technique, and is amazing. See below!

PrinceMichaelFan

yes legend x stans dragging.

Raava

No. Neither her voice or her vocal abilities are great. Both are pretty mediocre imo.

Kisuke

Quote:

Originally posted by PrinceMichaelFan

So you think hitting higher notes and having a long range makes you above Elvis or Bono? No shade to Whitney or Barbra but I Rolling Stone took more into consideration than just singing for their list which is why Beyonce isn't on the list.

Christina is the only pop star from this generation on the list.

Sorry sis in noway is a GREATEST Singers list valid when having Elvis in the top 5 while leaving off Barbra Streisand Placing Patti at 99 and having Bono there but no.
Natalie Cole.Kim Burrel,Anita Baker Jennifer Holiday,Chaka ?

Bmezy

You guys do realize that "vocal ABILITY" refers to the vocal techniques the singer uses, right??... it is the ABILITY of the voice--not the voice itself.

Kisuke

Quote:

Originally posted by D.M.F

The world, and critics do not care about technique. Even if that was the case, Beyonce would still not be considered an iconic vocalist.

Why do you think this raw powerful vocal performance overshadowed B's Listen 1 with ease?

BGK doesn't have a memorable Grammy performance for many reasons, while the voice of our generation's got multiple to her name.

How many awards did that performance give x in the years after it ?
Since she wowed them so much and gained so much respect as you claimed ?

EloiseheartsRiRi

Quote:

Originally posted by Kisuke

How many awards did that performance give x in the years after it ?
Since she wowed them so much and gained so much respect as you claimed ?

izzy™

Quote:

Originally posted by D.M.F

The world, and critics do not care about technique. Even if that was the case, Beyonce would still not be considered an iconic vocalist.

Why do you think this raw powerful vocal performance overshadowed B's Listen 1 with ease?

BGK doesn't have a memorable Grammy performance for many reasons, while the voice of our generation's got multiple to her name.

I love Legend X and I never said she didn't have beautiful powerful vocals. I know critics and other people don't care about technique but I still recognize that Beyoncé has a healthier technique.

Kisuke

Quote:

Originally posted by ImmaSlave4u

She is LIGHTYEARS better than Bey and I am not about to argue with a Rihanna stan about it

Explain ?

Also since she is light years better how come she had to cancel a entire tour leg cause she messed up her voice ? Also point me to Bey having to cancel more then an entire tour leg cause of vocal problems.

Bmezy

Quote:

Originally posted by Repo

You can buy a piano. You can't buy raw vocals like Xtina has. Your point is invalid and inaccurate

The point still stands.. you just changed the context..

So Xtina was given a beautiful voice...
What if I was given a mahogony Hamlin and Mason (special edition) grand...I didn't buy it?? It was a gift.. does that makes me a world class pianist because the INSTRUMENT is of seemingly high quality?? So I can take this one of a kind instrument and start playing twinkle twinkle little star, with the coordination of a small child and because it's a HAMLIN and MASON...I have just become a great musician, a child prodigy??
The parallels are clear, sis..

EloiseheartsRiRi

Quote:

Originally posted by Bmezy

The point still stands.. you just changed the context..

So Xtina was given a beautiful voice...
What if I was given a mahogony Hamlin and Mason (special edition) grand...I didn't buy it?? It was a gift.. does that makes me a world class pianist because the INSTRUMENT is of seemingly high quality?? So I can take this one of a kind instrument and start playing twinkle twinkle little star, with the coordination of a small child and because it's a HAMLIN and MASON...I have just become a great musician, a child prodigy??
The parallels are clear, sis..

This is elaborated so beautifully.

M André

Quote:

Originally posted by D.M.F

The truth can be hard to accept sometimes.

Rolling Stone: 100 Greatest Singers Of All Time -

58 | Christina Aguilera
79 | Mariah Carey
N/a | Beyonce

Critics, and the world have spoken. It's time to deal, and give Legend X credit.

That list means nothing honey and the fact that many amazing singers like Ella Fitzgerald arent even there and that ****ing Bob Marley made the list proves it.
Also the fact that Christina has a good voice doesnt mean that she's a good vocalist, it takes more than a cute tone to be a great vocalist.