This is for strictly those who stan for at least one the current main pop girls: Rihanna, Katy, Beyonce, Taylor.

Katy: Music is too generic and has no substance
Beyonce: unrelateable
Taylor: Too one-dimensional.


Your turn

Katy: I used to stan for her, but she became childish.
Taylor: I don't like her music.

Katy: her music is fun to listen to but I can't imagine defending her artistry/talent
Taylor: I've only heard like 6 of her songs and they're okay nothing special
Rihanna: love her music but she needs to improve her live vocals
Pink: not really into the music she makes
Gaga: eh I basically was stanning years ago, still love her just not a stan
Ariana: same as rihanna, needs to improve her voice

Katy: Her live vocals, lackluster performances, her discography.
Beyonce: I like her but thievery
Rihanna: I like her but she lacks substance and doesn't write her own material. Improved immensely in the live performance department tho.
Madonna: tshirt, swag, Dark_Lorde, and the other one. Not good anymore.

PerchedT for the mess.

I only stan for the best, the one who deserves my praise, the one and only Beyoncé.


I like Gaga too.

Katy: her music is trash
Beyonce: her music is trash
Gaga: just cringeworthy
Britney: no good anymore
Madonna: no good anymore

Katy: her kid-friendly music is getting a little bit boring, but I do bop to some of her old material
Gaga: her attitude towards her "downfall" and lack of interest in her new material bothers me a little bit. I do like Gaga's music, but I wish she would understand what the GP and her fans are telling her. Yes, she an artist and should be in charge of her craft, but I do miss the previous Gaga that merged art with music without trying hard.
Britney: She's the true Princess of Pop, and I do bop to some of her older material as well, but it seems that she lost her passion a while ago, and her recent material does nothing for me (even tho I find BJ not that bad as people say).
Taylor: country Taylor wasn't my favorite, I did enjoy some of her recent songs in 1989. I do appreciate the fact that she's a talented and relatable songwritter tho.
Iggy: I don't get the hype, and I said this since day one. I don't get the hate as well, but that's another topic. Her music doesn't nothing for me tbh, and I don't think she's on Nicki or Azelea's level at all. But she has a lot of time to grow.
Ariana: great voice, still think she can't control it properly sometimes. Should go in a different direction with her recent material in order to be the "next Mariah".

I only stan for Beyoncé tbh.
Still, I do follow Rihanna, Nicki and P!nk

Lack of talent / Good songs / Originality, creativity....

It's honestly down to the music, i just like the music that my fave makes the most
(+ she cracks me up, she's relatable, down to earth and she reinvents herself a lot)

Katy: Doesn't write her songs (at least that's what I believe), generic sound, too marketable, lacks personality.
Rihanna: Doesn't write her songs, also too marketable, lots of fillers on her discography keep me from enjoying her even as a casual listener
Madonna: She's a bad bitch but nowadays she acts like a teenager and her voice has grown weak. It's sad to stan for someone that you know will never deliver a good song again - vocally speaking
Beyoncé - Love her music since 4, but she doesn't seem authentic to me. Just a puppet.

Katy: great personality and catchy pop songs but her live performances are either hit or miss and they're mostly misses.
Taylor: Same as Katy + I can't help but wonder if she's an absolute mean girl bts. I just get that vibe from her.
Gaga: She's not as interesting [musically] as she was before and I just don't like her
Britney: I was too young to care when she was an amazing performer + her music isn't all that to me like most people. Then again, I wasn't into the bubblegum pop scene from the early 2000s besides BSB and NSYNC.

Katy: I like her music but she's just not Bey or Taylor level imo
Britney: She's so fake and can't sing or dance.

Katy : Boring.
Bey : Low key do, but not fully.
Taylor : Her music is good and she's nice, but I don't find her that interesting.

Katy: Cute bops but that's not close to being enough

Taylor: I couldn't care less about her other than her great discography

Gaga: I despise ARTPOP, DWUW is still Jesus in song form though

Why do you think she's a puppet?

She doesn't even have a manager.

I honestly don't stan for any major pop girls. I love Rihanna, but I'm not a stan. Same for Bey.

I guess if you consider Ariana a major girl, but I feel she needs one more solid era first. Nicki don't count either.

Why do you stan for them? From my perspective they're mediocre.