Celeb News: Blake Shelton: American Idol got lucky

tj hazuki

Quote:

“I think mostly because people like that are one in a million,” Shelton told BuzzFeed News. “The odds of American Idol having done that are astronomical. I don’t think it’s … because of that show — it was just luck of the draw that those two girls came strolling through those auditions. If it was just the result of a show, then there would be 30 superstars right now that have come out of all these shows. But it’s not. It’s just people, whether it’s on one of these shows, or YouTube, or somebody who got a record deal and got on the radio. You never know where they’re going to come from, and it just so happens that they had a couple.”

http://www.mjsbigblog.com/blake-shel...superstars.htm

Yeah, American Idol got lucky

What about Chris Daughtry, Philip Phillips? Hell even Katharine McPhee Jennifer Hudson,eetc done okay for themselves. Scotty McCerry and Kelie Pickler in the country scene is doing alight too..

Don't see where Blake is going wit this one.. I don't think the voice will ever produce a star. Even XFUSA produced 5H.

Silence.

You're using Chris Daughtry to argue for American Idol's success rate at bringing out stars?

I mean... there are so much better examples that that just came me burst out laughing.

Pelvic Thrust

He's funny.

Euphoric

Quote:

Originally posted by Silence.

You're using Chris Daughtry to argue for American Idol's success rate at bringing out stars?

I mean... there are so much better examples that that just came me burst out laughing.

Tell me did the voice even produce any chris daughtry in terms of success? Hell not even close.

Ger-55

Quote:

Originally posted by Silence.

You're using Chris Daughtry to argue for American Idol's success rate at bringing out stars?

I mean... there are so much better examples that that just came me burst out laughing.

He with his band is one of the most sucessful acts, he even destroyed most of the winners

tj hazuki

Quote:

Originally posted by Silence.

You're using Chris Daughtry to argue for American Idol's success rate at bringing out stars?

I mean... there are so much better examples that that just came me burst out laughing.

Uh, Chris Daughty and his band is successful and more successful than any Voice winner so far. HELL Even Lee DeWye abum sales is BETTER than most voice winner sales.

Royal Culture

Luck isn't a good excuse, The Voice has failed to produce anyone as successful as Idol's least successful winner.

aboynamedginger

America Idol created superstars, pure and simple. He's out of his mind.

MissedTheTrain

I think its partially true. It depends on the person, and The Voice hasn't found anyone with that special quality yet. But at the same time I think the format is just kinda stale. Phillip Phillips is the last successful act that Idol has spawned off, and that was in 2012, not long after The Voice started.

Another reason is I think The Voice has always put too much emphasis on the coaches. Everything is from the coaches' perspective...you don't get to know the contestants that well, and they aren't depicted as stars the way they are on XF or Idol. On shows like TXF or Idol, they really build up the contestants and make them look like big stars already, and it helps that they make those shows a little more dramatic.

Carrie-is-no-1

He's trolling his best friends KC and CU

KillingYourCareer

Quote:

Originally posted by Carrie-is-no-1

He's trolling his best friends KC and CU

Exactly what I thought

rac7d

Quote:

Originally posted by tj hazuki

http://www.mjsbigblog.com/blake-shel...superstars.htm

Yeah, American Idol got lucky

What about Chris Daughtry, Philip Phillips? Hell even Katharine McPhee Jennifer Hudson,eetc done okay for themselves. Scotty McCerry and Kelie Pickler in the country scene is doing alight too..

Don't see where Blake is going wit this one.. I don't think the voice will ever produce a star. Even XFUSA produced 5H.

But he is right

they did get lucky the joke behind AI is that havent been able to create a consistent star aside from Kell and carrie, the runner up who use it as a luanching pad do not count.