I've seen so many Beys posting that Single Ladies is more iconic than any Rihanna song. Is this true?
Or is Umbrella/WFL more iconic.

Lol. I could think of at least 5 Rihanna songs that are more iconic than Single Ladies. Also, so is Crazy In Love.

Oh, I stan for both, I'm legit curious what the rest of y'all think.

Are we talking about sales or cultural relevance?

Well rihannas singles has more global impacT so...

Umbrella

SL is iconic for the video really .!

.

but we all know the real answer is no

Umbrella because it was actually a worldwide hit, number one in many countries!

Even though I like both Rih songs more, "Single Ladies" takes the cake.

There is no point of this.
Rihanna fans be like: 14 (or however #1's she has) speak for themselves!!111! she is more global! IMPACT! icon!
And Beyonce fans be like: SiL was VIRAL! everybody was doing it! Beyonce has longevity + her singles aren;t forgotten!

So yeah lol

No.

Everything.

Several

why do people think that matters when it takes like 5 sales to get No.1 in most minor markets?

This is a online forum where people discuss their opinions.
What's the point of this comment?

In that case:
Sales: Rihanna > Beyoncé
Cultural Relevance: Beyoncé > Rihanna

I think one could say Umbrella and Single Ladies both had the same amount of impact. In different forms, but they equate in the long run, IMO.

But I stan for both, so maybe I'm just neutral by choice.

No